Freethought & Rationalism Archive

Sabine Grant · 06-13-2003, 04:50 AM

Messianic jews I meant to type not messaic...... noticed my typo too late after I posted to be able to edit.

Primordial Groove · 06-13-2003, 09:44 AM

Quote:

Bonjour Primordial Grove..... I was summoned back to your thread. A simple PM will do next time. Thank you !

I'll summon you anyway I desire. Of course it is up to you to respond to that summons. Thank you!!

Quote:

Ponce Pilate who was presented as the official rep. of the Roman Government in Galilee found him not guilty of any crimes against Ceasar. Unless you can show me in the Gospels where PP declares him guilty of any crimes against Ceasar.

Never did I say he commited crimes against Caesar. He was a criminal. He lived under Roman rule. Therefore....

Quote:

Can you please provide biographical evidence that according to the Gospels Christ was neither a jew by ancestry nor was he practising judaism?

Why would I attempt to provide this evidence when this isn't a claim I have made? This was your assertion, not mine. Regardless of his ancestry, he still got nailed like a common criminal.

Quote:

They pushed for his arrest and execution as he had denounced their ill intent to manipulate masses by misrepresenting God. He accuses them of having killed God's prophets.

Hence, the blasphemy.

Quote:

Please provide scriptures from the Gospels to support your arguments. Thanks.

You keep asking for proof from the bible, but why would I? The true story of his blasphemous life would not be printed therein. One of the measures of control used by the bible is by painting their supposed savior (heathen) as a child of God.

And what proof do you want? I had questions for you that you provided answers for, nothing more. Yet, you seem to want proof of something I never asserted. I asked you why he was killed like a common criminal, and you provided the history to his criminal, blasphemous ways. Thank you!!

Sabine Grant · 06-14-2003, 06:19 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Primordial Groove
I'll summon you anyway I desire. Of course it is up to you to respond to that summons. Thank you!!

Never did I say he commited crimes against Caesar. He was a criminal. He lived under Roman rule. Therefore....

Why would I attempt to provide this evidence when this isn't a claim I have made? This was your assertion, not mine. Regardless of his ancestry, he still got nailed like a common criminal.

Hence, the blasphemy.

You keep asking for proof from the bible, but why would I? The true story of his blasphemous life would not be printed therein. One of the measures of control used by the bible is by painting their supposed savior (heathen) as a child of God.

And what proof do you want? I had questions for you that you provided answers for, nothing more. Yet, you seem to want proof of something I never asserted. I asked you why he was killed like a common criminal, and you provided the history to his criminal, blasphemous ways. Thank you!!

I think you might have to comply to the Administration rules before you decide to use your own means to " summon" anyone.( see reply from Writer At Large to your " summon" entitled " Sabine Grant" in the General Discussion Forum).

You did state that Christ was against the Roman government. Then doubted his " jewishness". Your post speaks for itself.

You made a statement and you were challenged to support it with other arguments than your rant. You failed to do so. I can see why that thread was moved to " Elsewhere".

I gave you an opportunity to make it a " real discussion". You do not wish to use that opportunity..... I do not have any more time to waste.
I stand on my arguments.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

06-13-2003, 04:50 AM	#11
Sabine Grant Talk Freethought Staff Join Date: Aug 2002 Location: Florida Posts: 32,364	Messianic jews I meant to type not messaic...... noticed my typo too late after I posted to be able to edit.

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.