motorhead

I'd like to hear your thoughts on Victor Frankl's book "Man's Search For Meaning". I have nearly finished reading it.

Frankl claims that the meaning life changes from one day to the next, even moment to moment. If Frankl means by "meaning of life" one's larger meaning and purpose then I disagree. I think your larger meaning and purpose is something that's figured out (probably over a lengthy time period) and is embedded at a deeper level within oneself. I think this deeper meaning and purpose directs all your attitudes and actions in life. Circumstances may change but your meaning and purpose doesn't change day to day or moment to moment. If your meaning and purpose do change, it's usually a lengthy change process.

Frankl seems to have stated that one should find a meaning to life. I agree with him that each person has to find their own meaning and purpose in life but the question is what should this meaning and purpose be based on? Your meaning and purpose is based on your beliefs. Is it important that these beliefs be based on facts? Is it ok for someone to invent beliefs and base their lives on it as long as it makes them fairly well-adjusted and happy?

I'm questioning this because at one point Frankl seems to be stating that as long as the person's beliefs make them happy and they're live a fulfilling life, then the beliefs are ok. An example is his advice to the Rabbi who came to him for counsel.

In all fairness to Frankl, I understand that his detailed theory is outlined in something like 20 volumes. He may address some of these issues in one of the 20 volumes. At least you'd like to think so, since he wrote 20 volumes on this theory.

Thoughts?

sakrilege

First, I have not read the book nor am I familiar with Victor Frankl.


I would agree with you here. So many people in all societies live a very routine life. Raising children requires a certain amount of stability for 10-20 years. People do change and some change quickly but the minute to minute idea seems extreme.


Many slave owners were quite happy and led fulfilling lives. Does Frankl address issues like this? Maybe in one of the 20 volumes!!

Susan

[ September 26, 2002: Message edited by: sakrilege ]</p>

Bree

I think this topic is a bit too "deep" for the lower forums and deserves to be discussed. I'm moving it to Philosopy for that reason.