FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Archives > Religion (Closed) > Biblical Criticism & History
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Today at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 06-05-2006, 12:04 AM   #131
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 111
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by fromdownunder
OK, I'll make you happy. The link would not work on my PC, so please explain. But if you are going to use the separate lineage Joseph/Mary argument, or Leverite marriage, don't even bother.

An explanation based on what the Bible actually says in context, in the verses which cite the genaeologies would work for me.

Norm
I've done business with quite a few Jews. For never having a Passover, or being enslaved in Egypt, they sure know what tribe they are from. You know the twelve tribes of Isreal?

Everyone of them I have talked to knows.

Just like every white American knows what country they came from in Europe.

There is history in your origins.

I would think the Jews wouldn't celebrate Passover because they would pretend they were enslaved.
Patriarch Verlch is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 12:07 AM   #132
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the dark places of the world
Posts: 8,093
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Patriarch Verlch
Never enslaved in Egypt? Wow you guys are trying to rewrite History aren't you?
There is no historical evidence that this ever happened.

If you think otherwise, feel free to make fools of all of us and post the evidence here.

Quote:
Godidit is looking better all the time.
Only to those without an education in science. You're like the person who looks at a flashlight for the first time and assumes it must be magic. Lacking the understanding - and also lacking the tools to even begin to investigate the flashlight - you fall back on superstition.

Hint: the Creation/Evolution forum exists for a reason. Go discover what that reason is.

Quote:
Until you can arise life out of primordial soup, your theory is nothing more than a theory. An elaborate one, drawn up in the highest places on earth.
Thus proving that you don't understand even what "theory" means in science.
Sauron is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 12:11 AM   #133
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the dark places of the world
Posts: 8,093
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Patriarch Verlch
I've done business with quite a few Jews. For never having a Passover, or being enslaved in Egypt, they sure know what tribe they are from. You know the twelve tribes of Isreal?

Everyone of them I have talked to knows.
Correction: every one of them is convinced that they know. In reality, few of them can prove anything, since after the last destruction of the Temple the bloodlines were not carefully recorded.

Quote:
Just like every white American knows what country they came from in Europe.
And in like fashion, many white Americans are merely repeating what they are told, without any way to verify it. That is not knowledge.

Quote:
I would think the Jews wouldn't celebrate Passover because they would pretend they were enslaved.
And Muslims practice the hajj and throw rocks at the devil on the plain of Arafat, because they believe that Muhammad did the same thing when Satan was trying to stop him from spreading Islam. Millions of Muslims make this trip every year; surely they wouldn't spend all that time and money on the trip if the story wasn't true.

Right?
Sauron is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 12:12 AM   #134
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: USA
Posts: 5,393
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Patriarch Verlch
I would think the Jews wouldn't celebrate Passover because they would pretend they were enslaved.
Along the same lines, you would think that the Muslims wouldn't revere Muhammad unless he really ascended to Heaven.

(I see my friend Sauron has beat me to it... )
Dr Rick is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 12:14 AM   #135
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 111
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sauron
Yes, and we celebrate Christmas every year. That must prove that Santa Claus with his eight reindeer actually make the trip, right?


It isn't that hard to understand it, providing that you have a basis in the relevant science. Or, providing that you are willing to learn the science needed. I doubt you qualify on either count.


Except that:

1. there is zero evidence that Noah existed; and

2. zero evidence of any such flood - of course, if you disagree, you can take the same challenge I gave to one allegiance: wander over to our Creation/Evolution forum and read up on the subject. Then when you feel like your courage is strong enough, open a thread over there and try to defend it.


Is it? List the extra-biblical source.

Guys I don't think Plato or Aristotle existed now after talking to you. I don't believe they actually wrote what you say they did, I need extra textual sources centuries later that prove they existed, I don't think they were human either.

I need birth certificates and SSN numbers.


I will also need a video taped excerpt of Charles Darwin writing the origin of species, to ensure he didn't plagiarise. I am going to need signed affidavits in front of a grand jury from Charles Darwin's in laws to ensure he was who he said he was. I will also need fingerprints and a DNA sample, and a swab of saliva.

Yeah that sounds like fun, reading up on evolution from those you disagree with.

I've got a bible in front of me, perhaps I can COD it to you and you can get "informed."

You choose to interpret the data taht there was a flood, to conform to your naturalist views, overlooked by peer direction/science. Hint your thoughts are not actually your own.
Patriarch Verlch is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 12:17 AM   #136
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the dark places of the world
Posts: 8,093
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by one allegiance
I guess so. You can ask any educated scholar, atheist or not, about this one. They wont deny Jesus's existence,
You keep repeating this. Are you not aware that your own source, Wikipedia, calls you a liar on it?

There really are scholars that deny any such Jesus person ever existed. There is even an entire movement around it; it's called the "Jesus Myth". Most scholars will not go so far as to say that no such man ever existed. But your claim that no such scholars exist is (a) flatly incorrect and (b) only shows that you are not up to date on the current status of New Testament scholarship.
Sauron is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 12:21 AM   #137
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the dark places of the world
Posts: 8,093
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Patriarch Verlch
Guys I don't think Plato or Aristotle existed now after talking to you.
The evidence for Plato and Aristotle, when compared to the claims, is much better than it is for Christ, when compared to the claims. Let me introduce you to another principle of investigation: extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Quote:
I will also need a video taped excerpt of Charles Darwin writing the origin of species, to ensure he didn't plagiarise.
Origin does not suffer from the problems that the gospels do, so plagiarization isn't a concern.

Quote:
I am going to need signed affidavits in front of a grand jury from Charles Darwin's in laws to ensure he was who he said he was. I will also need fingerprints and a DNA sample, and a swab of saliva.
DNA and saliva don't prove authorship. IN your rush to create what you thought was a clever response, you jumped off the rails into irrelevancy.

Quote:
Yeah that sounds like fun, reading up on evolution from those you disagree with.
Whether it is fun or not is quite irrelevant. The point is that you do not understand evolution and have made several mistakes in your comments. That's why your objections are baseless.

Quote:
I've got a bible in front of me, perhaps I can COD it to you and you can get "informed."
Don't bother; I have several myself. That's the difference between you and me: I know what the other side is actually saying, and can accurately repeat their positions. I just disagree with them. You, on the other hand, can't even accurately repeat what the other side (evolution, bible skepticism) is saying. Instead of researching it yourself, you settle for having some sunday school teacher or christian author filter the information inaccurately for you, so that you can be spoon fed whatever mistakes they are making.

Quote:
You choose to interpret the data taht there was a flood, to conform to your naturalist views, overlooked by peer direction/science.
No, the data simply fails to support any such flood. Even you understand that, which is why -- in spite of repeated requests -- you've failed to offer any evidence.

Quote:
Hint your thoughts are not actually your own.
Hint: you're wrong.
Sauron is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 12:31 AM   #138
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 111
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sauron
The evidence for Plato and Aristotle, when compared to the claims, is much better than it is for Christ, when compared to the claims. Let me introduce you to another principle of investigation: extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.


Origin does not suffer from the problems that the gospels do, so plagiarization isn't a concern.



Hint: you're wrong.
Obviously those men had the establishment write and follow their every move. These men were not holy men like in the bible, so the secular world payed them loads of attention, while scantly mentioning the bible.

Well perhaps if Christ had the intellectual world baited at His every word and following Him instead of trying to kill Him at every turn, perhaps you would have more of what you need for your faith.

I am under the assumption that a face to face meeting with Christ would not change your mind, so what do you need details for? The life changing force of God can be within us all!!! I've felt it on more than one occasion.

Why do you mock that which you attempt to not understand?


On a side note.
What did the Knights of Templar find under King Solmon's temple? That caused them to stop looking and the wealthest man in the world to give everything to the order and serve it?
Patriarch Verlch is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 12:36 AM   #139
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the dark places of the world
Posts: 8,093
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Patriarch Verlch
Obviously those men had the establishment write and follow their every move. These men were not holy men like in the bible, so the secular world payed them loads of attention, while scantly mentioning the bible.
I have no idea if this is right or not. I don't know if they were ignored, or followed. Your assumption about them being secular is incorrect; Darwin was a divinity student, and the Englishman who founded uniformitarianism was a minister. I'm beginning to wonder what relevance it has?

Quote:
Well perhaps if Christ had the intellectual world baited at His every word and following Him instead of trying to kill Him at every turn, perhaps you would have more of what you need for your faith.
Christ was supposedly God. Overcoming something as trivial as people trying to kill him should have been quite easy; we ARE talking about the Almighty, aren't we?

Quote:
I am under the assumption that a face to face meeting with Christ would not change your mind, so what do you need details for?
1.The assumptions you make are your own. I am not responsible for them.

2. I need details for the claims you have made here. No more stalling: do you have the details, or don't you?

Quote:
The life changing force of God can be within us all!!! I've felt it on more than one occasion.
I have Muslim and Hindu friends who have said the same thing to me.

Quote:
Why do you mock that which you attempt to not understand?
Why do you assume that someone mocking you hasn't tried to understand your beliefs several times already?

Quote:
On a side note.
What did the Knights of Templar find under King Solmon's temple? That caused them to stop looking and the wealthest man in the world to give everything to the order and serve it?
1. Who cares?
2. Are you trying to write some kind of Da Vinci code sequel or something? Because this really isn't the place to try out your new screenplay.
Sauron is offline  
Old 06-05-2006, 01:09 AM   #140
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: LA
Posts: 645
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by one allegiance
This doesn't cease to amaze me. The only dispute was over Jesus's DIVINITY. Have you heard of the Council of Nicea. Have you heard of the Niceen creed. Have you heard of B.C. and A.D. Have you thought about where the word Christians comes from. These aren't coincidences. The council of nicaea is on of the biggest supports. They KNEW he was a real person. Constantine KNEW he was real. The council just had to basically found christianity. It also proves that the people who followed Jesus were real..
Have you heard of John Frum?

Quote:
The Jon Frum movement appeared for the first time in the 1940s in the New Hebrideans. At that time some 300,000 American troops established themselves in the New Hebrides. The islanders were impressed both by the egalitarianism of the Americans and their obvious wealth and power. This led them to conflate perceived benefactors such as Uncle Sam, Santa Claus and John the Baptist into a mythic figure called John Frum, who would empower the island peoples by giving them cargo wealth.
From here

Quote:
Nor are the younger John Frum members backwards or insular in their view of their religion. "God appeared to the people of Tanna in the form of John Frum", one tells me, "Just as he appeared to the Jews as Jesus, and to the Indians as Buddha.
They know he was a real person...

Quote:
To anthropologists, John Frum was an example of one of the strangest and most exotic phenomena to be observed in traditional cultures: the cargo cult. All across Melanesia, from New Guinea to the Solomon Islands to Tanna's archipelago, the New Hebrides, dozens of unconnected communities, thousands of miles apart and speaking unrelated languages, seemed spontaneously to generate the same set of bizarre beliefs. A new dispensation was on the way, when the white man would vanish from the islands, and his cargo - Western goods - would be diverted by magical means to the local people, who were its rightful owners.
Are these coincidences?
nelsondogg is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:04 PM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.