Freethought & Rationalism ArchiveThe archives are read only. |
11-02-2011, 12:22 AM | #1 |
Veteran Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: seattle, wa
Posts: 9,337
|
1 Corinthians Chapters 14, 15 and 16 Are Fakes
I have been literally going through every reference to the First Letter to the Corinthians in the Writings of Clement of Alexandria. I found that he cites just about every other line of the material which appears before chapter 14. Once we get there he knows almost nothing about any of the material. There are forty lines in chapter 14, I am not even sure he ever knew anything from this section (perhaps a line). There are fifty eight lines in chapter 15 we can be certain only that Clement cited two maybe three lines here and nothing from chapter 16 which has twent four lines in total.
In other words Clement knows only a half a dozen of the final three chapters or one hundred and twenty lines of 1 Corinthians. More interesting perhaps is that almost no pre-Nicene Church Father knows anything about chapter 16. Here are the witnesses to that chapter: 1 Corinthians 16, 1 CPG2877 - CPL620 350 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Hieronymus presbyter (1 work(s)) Hieronymus presbyter Epistulae 110-120 (2) Date: ca.350 - ca.420 Genre: Letter Theme: Undetermined Clavis: 620 Biblio: LABOURT J., Saint Jérôme, Lettres, t. 6, Collection des Universités de France, Paris 1958. 120 (p.124, l.17) BPH 120 (p.131, l.22) BPH 363 (2 pole(s)) Cappadocia, Minor Asia (1 ancient author(s)) Basilius Caesariensis (1 work(s)) Basilius Caesariensis Regulae morales (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.378 Genre: Rule Theme: Christian life Clavis: 2877 Biblio: PG 31, 691-869. 48 § 6 (p.772 - <) BP5 Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (2 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.187, l.22 - < )) BP6 Commentarius in xiii epistulas Paulinas A (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,1 (1966). (p.406, l.8 - <) BP6 370 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Hieronymus presbyter (1 work(s)) Hieronymus presbyter Aduersus Vigilantium (1) Date: ca.370 - ca.420 Genre: Controversy Theme: Undetermined Clavis: 611 Biblio: PL 23 (1883) 353-368. 13 (p.365) BPH 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (3 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De eleemosyna (3) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Christian life Clavis: 4382 Biblio: PG 51, 261-272. (p.262, l.17 - <) BPH (p.264, l.37 - <) BPH (p.267, l.12 - < >) BPH In epistulam ad Romanos homiliae 1-32 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4427 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi Commentarius in epistolam ad Romanos, PG 60 (1862). 30 (p.661, l.38 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (3) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.367, l.19 - <) BPH 43 (p.368, l.26 - <) BPH 43 (p.372, l.57) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.369) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 2 CPG2559 - CPL620 350 (2 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.12, l.4) BP7 Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Hieronymus presbyter (1 work(s)) Hieronymus presbyter Epistulae 110-120 (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.420 Genre: Letter Theme: Undetermined Clavis: 620 Biblio: LABOURT J., Saint Jérôme, Lettres, t. 6, Collection des Universités de France, Paris 1958. 120 (p.131, l.22) BPH 363 (2 pole(s)) Cappadocia, Minor Asia (1 ancient author(s)) Basilius Caesariensis (1 work(s)) Basilius Caesariensis Regulae morales (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.378 Genre: Rule Theme: Christian life Clavis: 2877 Biblio: PG 31, 691-869. 48 § 6 (p.772 - <) BP5 Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.187, l.22 - < )) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (4 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De eleemosyna (5) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Christian life Clavis: 4382 Biblio: PG 51, 261-272. (p.262, l.17 - <) BPH (p.264, l.54 - <) BPH (p.265, l.38) BPH (p.266, l.5 - <) BPH (p.267, l.12 - < >) BPH De laudibus sancti Pauli apostoli homiliae 1-7 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Panegyric Theme: Pastoral Clavis: 4344 Biblio: PG 50, 473-514. 4 (p.491, l.36 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (3) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.368, l.37 - <) BPH 43 (p.369, l.47 - <) BPH 43 (p.372, l.57) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Timotheum homiliae 1-10 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4437 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., PG 62 (1862). 1 (p.606, l.9 - <) BPH 1 (p.606, l.15 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.41) BPH (p.369) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 3 CPG2570 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (?) (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (?) De trinitate (PG) (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.450 Genre: Treatise Theme: Theology Clavis: 2570 Biblio: PG 39 (1858), 600-992. 3 23 (p.929 - <) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.188, l.13 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (3 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De eleemosyna (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Christian life Clavis: 4382 Biblio: PG 51, 261-272. (p.267, l.30 - < /) BPH (p.268, l.5 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.370, l.1 - <) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 12 (p.487, l.32) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.41) BPH (p.369) BPH |
11-02-2011, 12:25 AM | #2 |
Veteran Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: seattle, wa
Posts: 9,337
|
1 Corinthians 16, 4
CPG4382 - CPL620 350 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Hieronymus presbyter (1 work(s)) Hieronymus presbyter Epistulae 110-120 (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.420 Genre: Letter Theme: Undetermined Clavis: 620 Biblio: LABOURT J., Saint Jérôme, Lettres, t. 6, Collection des Universités de France, Paris 1958. 120 (p.124, l.17) BPH 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.188, l.21 - <) BP6 370 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Hieronymus presbyter (1 work(s)) Hieronymus presbyter Aduersus Vigilantium (1) Date: ca.370 - ca.420 Genre: Controversy Theme: Undetermined Clavis: 611 Biblio: PL 23 (1883) 353-368. 13 (p.365) BPH 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (4 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De eleemosyna (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Christian life Clavis: 4382 Biblio: PG 51, 261-272. (p.267, l.30 - < /) BPH (p.268, l.15 - <) BPH In epistulam ad Hebraeos homiliae 1-34 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4440 Biblio: PG 63 (1862) 9-236. (p.12, l.9 - <) BPH In epistulam ad Romanos homiliae 1-32 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4427 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi Commentarius in epistolam ad Romanos, PG 60 (1862). (p.392, l.41 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.370, l.19 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.41) BPH (p.369) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 5 CPG4428 - CPL184 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.189, l.5 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.370, l.35 - <) BPH 43 (p.370, l.43 - <) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 1 (p.383, l.6 - <) BPH 2 (p.408, l.9 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.369) BPH (p.376) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 6 CPG4427 - CPL184 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.189, l.5 - <) BP6 377 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis (1 work(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis Expositio Euangelii secundum Lucam (1) Date: ca.377 - ca.389 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 143 Biblio: ADRIAEN M., CCL 14 (1957), 1-400. 8 § 25 (p.307, l.280 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (3 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam ad Romanos homiliae 1-32 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4427 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi Commentarius in epistolam ad Romanos, PG 60 (1862). 29 (p.658, l.11 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (3) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.370, l.43 - <) BPH 43 (p.370, l.55) BPH 43 (p.371, l.3 - <) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 1 (p.383, l.6 - <) BPH 2 (p.409, l.10 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.369) BPH (p.376) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 7 CPG4428 - CPL184 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.189, l.13 - <) BP6 386 (2 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.371, l.5 - <) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 4 (p.419, l.49 - <) BPH Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis (1 work(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis Expositio de Psalmo CXVIII (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.390 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 141 Biblio: PETSCHENIG M., CSEL 62 (1913, réimpr. 1962). 2 § 26 (p.36, l.8) BP6 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.369) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 8 CPG2559 - s. n.0 201 (1 pole(s)) Anonyma (1 ancient author(s)) Anonyma (1 work(s)) Anonyma Prologi epistularum Pauli (1) Date: ca.201 - ca.400 Genre: Preface, Prolog Theme: Heresy Clavis: 0 Biblio: DE BRUYNE D., Prologues bibliques d'origine marcionite, Revue Bénédictine 24 (1907), 13-16. (p.14, l.3) BP2 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.12, l.8) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.189, l.23 - < )) BP6 377 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis (1 work(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis Expositio Euangelii secundum Lucam (1) Date: ca.377 - ca.389 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 143 Biblio: ADRIAEN M., CCL 14 (1957), 1-400. 8 § 25 (p.307, l.281 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.370, l.50 - <) BPH 43 (p.371, l.11 - <) BPH 4 In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 1 (p.384, l.28 - <) BPH 2 (p.394, l.24 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.37) BPH (p.369) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 9 CPG1450 - CPL184 248 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Origenes (1 work(s)) Origenes Commentarii in Matthaeum, libri XII-XIII (lat.) (1) Date: ca.248 - ca.249 (or much later) Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 1450 Biblio: KLOSTERMANN E., BENZ E., GCS 38 (1933). 14 (p.27, l.15 - <) BP3 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (5 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Commentarii in Ecclesiasten 11-12 (4) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2555 Biblio: BINDER G., LIESENBORGHS L., Didymos der Blinde, Kommentar zum Ecclesiastes (Tura-Papyrus), 6, Komm. zu Eccl. Kap. 11-12 (Papyrologische Texte und Abhandlungen 9), Bonn 1969. 349 § 25 (p.172, l.25 - <) BP7 350 § 1 (p.172, l.1 - <) BP7 350 § 9 (p.174, l.9 - <) BP7 352 § 10 (p.184, l.10) BP7 Commentarii in Psalmos 22-26,10 (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2550 Biblio: GRONEWALD M., Didymos der Blinde, Psalmenkommentar (Tura-Papyrus), 2, Kommentar zu Psalm 22-26,10 (Papyrologische Texte und Abhandlungen 4), Bonn 1968. 63 § 21 (p.28, l.21 - <) BP7 Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.12, l.9) BP7 Fragmenta in Epistulam secundam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2560 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 14-44. (p.19, l.29) BP7 Fragmenta in Psalmos (1) (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2551 Biblio: MUHLENBERG E., Psalmenkommentare aus der Katenenüberlieferung, 1 (Patristische Texte und Studien 15), Berlin - New York 1975, 121-375. § 205 (p.238, l.22 - <) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.189, l.23 - < )) BP6 377 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis (1 work(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis Expositio Euangelii secundum Lucam (1) Date: ca.377 - ca.389 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 143 Biblio: ADRIAEN M., CCL 14 (1957), 1-400. 8 § 25 (p.307, l.281 - <) BP6 386 (2 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 43 (p.371, l.15 - <) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 2 (p.394, l.24 - <) BPH Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis (1 work(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis Expositio de Psalmo CXVIII (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.390 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 141 Biblio: PETSCHENIG M., CSEL 62 (1913, réimpr. 1962). 2 § 26 (p.36, l.8) BP6 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.37) BPH (p.369) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 10 CPG1004 - s. n.0 201 (2 pole(s)) Anonyma (1 ancient author(s)) Anonyma (1 work(s)) Anonyma Prologi epistularum Pauli (1) Date: ca.201 - ca.400 Genre: Preface, Prolog Theme: Heresy Clavis: 0 Biblio: DE BRUYNE D., Prologues bibliques d'origine marcionite, Revue Bénédictine 24 (1907), 13-16. (p.14, l.3 - /) BP2 Apostolic Fathers (1 ancient author(s)) Clemens Romanus (Ps.) (1 work(s)) Clemens Romanus (Ps.) Ad uirgines epistulae duae (1) Date: ca.201 - ca.300 Genre: Letter Theme: Christian life Clavis: 1004 Biblio: FUNK F.X., DIEKAMP F., Patres Apostolici, 2, 3 éd., Tubingae 1913, 1-49. 1 13 § 3 (p.26, l.22) BP2 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.12, l.18) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (3) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.190, l.6 - <) BP6 (p.191, l.9 - <) BP6 (p.196, l.8 - /) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (4 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam ad Philippenses homiliae 1-15 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4432 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., PG 62 (1862). 9 (p.247, l.21 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (3) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). (p.12, l.24) BPH 14 (p.115, l.15 - <) BPH 44 (p.373, l.25 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Timotheum homiliae 1-18 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4436 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., PG 62 (1862). (p.502, l.49 - <) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 1 (p.384, l.17 - <) BPH 387 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (1 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De statuis homiliae homiliae 1-20 et 22ad populum Antiochenum (1) Date: ca.387 - ca.387 Genre: Homily Theme: Christian life Clavis: 4330 Biblio: PG 49, 15-222. 1 (p.20, l.23 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 11 CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.12, l.27) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.190, l.6 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (4 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam ad Philippenses homiliae 1-15 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4432 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., PG 62 (1862). 9 (p.247, l.21 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). (p.12, l.24) BPH 44 (p.374, l.29 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Timotheum homiliae 1-18 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4436 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., PG 62 (1862). (p.502, l.49 - <) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 1 (p.384, l.24 - <) BPH 387 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (1 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De statuis homiliae homiliae 1-20 et 22ad populum Antiochenum (1) Date: ca.387 - ca.387 Genre: Homily Theme: Christian life Clavis: 4330 Biblio: PG 49, 15-222. 1 (p.20, l.23 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH |
11-02-2011, 12:26 AM | #3 |
Veteran Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: seattle, wa
Posts: 9,337
|
1 Corinthians 16, 12
CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (2 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Actus in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2561 Biblio: CRAMER J.A., Catenae graecorum Patrum in Novum Testamentum, 3, Oxford 1838 (Hildesheim 1967), passim 21-413. (p.309, l.33 - <) BP7 Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (2) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.12, l.28) BP7 (p.13, l.1 - <) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.190, l.26 - < )) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (3 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In Acta apostolorum homiliae 1-55 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4426 Biblio: PG 60 (1862) 13-384. 40 (p.284, l.11 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.374, l.43 - <) BPH In epistulam secundam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-30 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4429 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In secundam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 23 (p.556, l.26 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH (p.428) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 13 CPG1411 - CPL184 239 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Origenes (2 work(s)) Origenes In Exodum homiliae XIII (latine Rufino interprete) 2nd � (2) Date: ca.239 - ca.242 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 1414 Biblio: BAEHRENS W.A., GCS 29 (1920), 145-279. 3 3 (p.170, l.14 - <) BP3 4 9 (p.182, l.24 - >) BP3 In Genesim homiliae XVI (latine Rufino interprete) (1) Date: ca.239 - ca.242 Genre: - Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 1411 Biblio: BAEHRENS W.A., GCS 29 (1920), 1-144. 8 10 (p.85, l.16) BP3 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.6 - <) BP7 357 (1 pole(s)) Cappadocia, Minor Asia (1 ancient author(s)) Basilius Caesariensis (2 work(s)) Basilius Caesariensis Epistulae (t. II) (1) Date: ca.357 - ca.378 Genre: Letter Theme: Christian life Clavis: 2900 Biblio: COURTONNE Y., Saint Basile, Lettres, 2 (Collection des Universités de France), Paris 1961. 161 § 2 (p.93, l.1) BP5 Epistulae (t. III) (1) Date: ca.357 - ca.378 Genre: Letter Theme: Christian life Clavis: 2900 Biblio: COURTONNE Y., Saint Basile, Lettres, 3 (Collection des Universités de France), Paris 1966. 251 § 4 (p.93, l.22) BP5 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (2 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.191, l.12 - <) BP6 Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas C (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,3 (1969). (p.316, l.15) BP6 374 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis (1 work(s)) Ambrosius Mediolanensis Epistulae III (1) Date: ca.374 - ca.397 Genre: Letter Theme: Undetermined Clavis: 160 Biblio: ZELZER M., CSEL 82,3 (1982), 3-6 ; 11-20 ; 34-81 ; 108-140 ; 145-161 ; 178-221 ; 235-295 ; 302-311 ; 315-325. 14 § 41 (p.256, l.418) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (3 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus Homiliae 1-90 in Matthaeum (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4424 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi Commentarius in sanctum Matthaeum evangelistam, PG 57 et 58 (1862). 46 (p.476, l.55 - <) BPH In epistulam ad Ephesios homiliae 1-24 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4431 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., PG 62 (1862). 23 (p.163, l.42 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.375, l.2 - <) BPH 44 (p.375, l.5 - <) BPH 420 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Explanatio in Canticum Canticorum (2) Date: ca.420 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6203 Biblio: PG 91, 28-213. (p.93) BPH (p.149) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 14 CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.7) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.191, l.12 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (1 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.375, l.5 - <) BPH 44 (p.375, l.9 - <) BPH 420 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Explanatio in Canticum Canticorum (2) Date: ca.420 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6203 Biblio: PG 91, 28-213. (p.93) BPH (p.149) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 15 CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.9) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.192, l.5 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (3 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De laudibus sancti Pauli apostoli homiliae 1-7 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Panegyric Theme: Pastoral Clavis: 4344 Biblio: PG 50, 473-514. 3 (p.485, l.44 - <) BPH In epistulam ad Philippenses homiliae 1-15 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4432 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., PG 62 (1862). 13 (p.280, l.25 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (3) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 2 (p.18, l.30 - <) BPH 44 (p.375, l.26 - <) BPH 44 (p.376, l.6 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 16 CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.13 - <) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.192, l.5 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De laudibus sancti Pauli apostoli homiliae 1-7 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Panegyric Theme: Pastoral Clavis: 4344 Biblio: PG 50, 473-514. 3 (p.485, l.44 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.375, l.55 - <) BPH 44 (p.376, l.1 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 17 CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.15) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.192, l.16 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (1 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). (p.12, l.15) BPH 44 (p.376, l.9 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 18 CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.16 - <) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (2) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.192, l.16 - <) BP6 (p.193, l.1 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus De laudibus sancti Pauli apostoli homiliae 1-7 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Panegyric Theme: Pastoral Clavis: 4344 Biblio: PG 50, 473-514. 3 (p.485, l.46 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.376, l.9 - <) BPH 44 (p.376, l.27 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.372) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 19 CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.24 - <) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.193, l.10 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam ad Romanos homiliae 1-32 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4427 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi Commentarius in epistolam ad Romanos, PG 60 (1862). 30 (p.664, l.50 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.376, l.38 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.373) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 20 CPG2102 - CPL184 329 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Athanasius Alexandrinus (2 work(s)) Athanasius Alexandrinus Epistulae festales 1 ; 6 ; 24-29 ; 36-43 (copt.) (5) Date: ca.329 - ca.371 Genre: Letter Theme: Faith and Christian Reflection Clavis: 2102 Biblio: LEFORT L.Th., CSCO 151 (1955) 2 ; 8 ; 9-54. 25 (p.16, l.21 - <) BPH 26 (p.17, l.32 - <) BPH 36 (p.27, l.31 - )) BPH 39 (p.40, l.17 - <) BPH 42 (p.48, l.10 - <) BPH Epistulae festales 1-7 ; 11-14 ; 17-20 (syr.) (11) Date: ca.329 - ca.348 Genre: Letter Theme: Faith and Christian Reflection Clavis: 2102 Biblio: PG 26 (1857), 1360-1397 ; 1403-1432. 1 § 11 (p.1366 - <) BPH 2 § 7 (p.1371 - <) BPH 3 § 6 (p.1376 - <) BPH 4 § 5 (p.1379 - <) BPH 5 § 6 (p.1383 - <) BPH 6 § 12 (p.1389 - <) BPH 7 § 10 (p.1397 - <) BPH 11 § 15 (p.1412 - <) BPH 12 § 2 (p.1414 - <) BPH 13 § 8 (p.1418 - <) BPH 19 § 10 (p.1430 - <) BPH 348 (1 pole(s)) Palestine (1 ancient author(s)) Cyrillus Hierosolymitanus (?) (1 work(s)) Cyrillus Hierosolymitanus (?) Mystagogiae 1-5 (1) Date: ca.348 - ca.399 Genre: Catechesis Theme: Pastoral Clavis: 3586 Biblio: PIEDAGNEL A., PARIS P., SC 126 (1966). 5 § 3 (p.150, l.13 - < /) BP4 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.26) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.193, l.19 - <) BP6 367 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Athanasius Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Athanasius Alexandrinus Epistulae festales 39-41 (1) Date: ca.367 - ca.369 Genre: Letter Theme: Faith and Christian Reflection Clavis: 2102 Biblio: COQUIN R.-G., Les Lettres festales d'Athanase (CPG 2102), un nouveau complément : le manuscrit IFAO copte 25, planche X, Orientalia Lovaniensia Periodica 15 (1984),152-158. 40 (p.155, l.14 - <) BPH 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus Catecheses ad illuminandos 2-3 (Pi�gnel-Doutreleau) (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Catechesis Theme: Pastoral Clavis: 4461 Biblio: PAPADOPOULOS-KERAMEUS A., Varia graeca sacra, Petropoli 1909, 154-175. (p.175, l.20 - /) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.376, l.44 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.373) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 21 CPG2559 - CPL184 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.13, l.28 - )) BP7 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.193, l.25 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (2 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam ad Romanos homiliae 1-32 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4427 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi Commentarius in epistolam ad Romanos, PG 60 (1862). 32 (p.680, l.31 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.376, l.57 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.373) BPH |
11-02-2011, 12:26 AM | #4 |
Veteran Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: seattle, wa
Posts: 9,337
|
1 Corinthians 16, 22
CPG1735 - CPL620 101 (1 pole(s)) Anonyma (1 ancient author(s)) Anonyma (1 work(s)) Anonyma Doctrina XII apostolorum (Didache) (1) Date: ca.101 - ca.200 Genre: Treatise Theme: Christian Mystery Clavis: 1735 Biblio: FUNK F.X.,BIHLMEYER K., Die apostolischen Väter, Neubearbeitung der Funkschen Ausgabe, 2e éd., Tübingen 1956, 1-9. 10 § 6 (p.6, l.26) BP1 217 (1 pole(s)) Africa (1 ancient author(s)) Tertullianus (1 work(s)) Tertullianus De pudicitia (1) Date: ca.217 - ca.222 Genre: Treatise Theme: Christian life Clavis: 30 Biblio: DEKKERS E., CCL 2 (1954), 1281-1330. 14 § 13 (p.1308, l.49) BP1 350 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Fragmenta in Epistulam primam ad Corinthios in catenis (1) Date: ca.350 - ca.398 Genre: Catena Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2559 Biblio: STAAB K., Pauluskommentare aus der griechischen Kirche aus Katenenhandschriften gesammelt, Münster 1933, 6-14. (p.14, l.2 - <) BP7 356 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Athanasius Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Athanasius Alexandrinus Epistula ad monachos (1) Date: ca.356 - ca.361 Genre: Letter Theme: Dogma Clavis: 2126 Biblio: OPITZ H.-G., Athanasius Werke, 2,1, Berlin - Leipzig 1935, 181-182. § 3 (p.182, l.25 - <) BPH 359 (1 pole(s)) Cappadocia, Minor Asia (1 ancient author(s)) Gregorius Nazianzenus (1 work(s)) Gregorius Nazianzenus Epistulae theologicae (CI, CII, CCII) (2) Date: ca.359 - ca.390 Genre: Letter Theme: Theology Clavis: 3032 Biblio: GALLAY P., SC 208 (1974). 101 § 22 (p.46, l.6) BP5 101 § 30 (p.48, l.10) BP5 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (2 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.194, l.1 - <) BP6 Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas C (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,3 (1969). (p.57, l.26 - < )) BP6 370 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Hieronymus presbyter (1 work(s)) Hieronymus presbyter Epistulae 23-52 (1) Date: ca.370 - ca.420 Genre: Letter Theme: Undetermined Clavis: 620 Biblio: LABOURT J., Saint Jérôme, Lettres, t. 2, Collection des Universités de France,Paris 1951. 26 (p.16, l.10 - <) BPH 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (3 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus Aduersus Iudaeos et Iuda�ntes sermones 1-7 et in eos qui prima Pascha ieiunant homilia (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.387 Genre: Homily Theme: From Judaism to Christianity Clavis: 4327 Biblio: PG 48,843-942. 2 (p.862, l.10 - <) BPH In epistulam ad Romanos homiliae 1-32 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4427 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi Commentarius in epistolam ad Romanos, PG 60 (1862). 16 (p.549, l.14 - <) BPH 31 (p.670, l.27 - <) BPH In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (2) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.376, l.60 - <) BPH 44 (p.377, l.8 - <) BPH 387 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Didymus Alexandrinus Commentarii in Zachariam (1) Date: ca.387 - ca.393 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 2549 Biblio: DOUTRELEAU L., SC 83 (1962) : livre 1 ; SC 84 (1962) : livres 2 et 3 ; SC 85 (1962) : livres 4 et 5. 5 389 (p.1036, l.23 - <) BP7 420 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Explanatio in Canticum Canticorum (1) Date: ca.420 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6203 Biblio: PG 91, 28-213. (p.93) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (2) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.149) BPH (p.373) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 23 CANT245 - CPL184 201 (1 pole(s)) Anonyma (1 ancient author(s)) Anonyma apocrypha (2 work(s)) Anonyma apocrypha Acta Thomae 1 (1) Date: ca.201 - ca.300 Genre: Acts Theme: Apocrypha Clavis: 245 Biblio: WRIGHT W., Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles, 2, London 1871, 146-298. (p.156, l.22 - P) BP2 Acta Thomae 1' (1) Date: ca.201 - ca.300 Genre: Acts Theme: Apocrypha Clavis: 245 Biblio: § 13 (p.119, l.3) BP2 356 (1 pole(s)) Alexandria (1 ancient author(s)) Athanasius Alexandrinus (1 work(s)) Athanasius Alexandrinus Epistula ad monachos (1) Date: ca.356 - ca.361 Genre: Letter Theme: Dogma Clavis: 2126 Biblio: OPITZ H.-G., Athanasius Werke, 2,1, Berlin - Leipzig 1935, 181-182. § 3 (p.182, l.25 - <) BPH 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.194, l.7 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (1 work(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus In epistulam primam ad Corinthios homiliae 1-44 (1) Date: ca.386 - ca.403 Genre: Homily Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 4428 Biblio: MIGNE J.-P., Sancti Joannis Chrysostomi In Primam ad Corinthios epistolam commentarius, PG 61 (1862). 44 (p.377, l.28 - <) BPH 423 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri (1 work(s)) Theodoretus episcopus Cyri Interpretatio in epistulas Paulinas (1) Date: ca.423 - ca.460 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 6209 Biblio: PG 82 (1864), 36-877. (p.373) BPH 1 Corinthians 16, 24 CPG4428 - CPL184 363 (1 pole(s)) Italy (1 ancient author(s)) Ambrosiaster (1 work(s)) Ambrosiaster Commentarius in epistulas Paulinas B (1) Date: ca.363 - ca.384 Genre: Commentary Theme: Exegesis, Scripture Commentaries Clavis: 184 Biblio: VOGELS H.I., CSEL 81,2 (1968). (p.194, l.7 - <) BP6 386 (1 pole(s)) Antioch, Syria (1 ancient author(s)) Iohannes Chrysostomus (1 work(s)) |
11-02-2011, 02:45 AM | #5 |
Contributor
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Barrayar
Posts: 11,866
|
Interesting topic. Pray continue. Do you think the odd mentions of 1 Cor 16 in the pre-nicene dads are interpolations, or was some of the material elsewhere in Paul
|
11-02-2011, 03:35 AM | #6 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Darwin, Australia
Posts: 874
|
For novices in this area can you answer silly questions like what Irenaeus and Tertullian know about 1 Corinthians?
|
11-02-2011, 03:54 AM | #7 | |
Banned
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: middle east
Posts: 829
|
Quote:
May I ask, from ignorance, not as one who has actually read Irenaeus, or any of the other preNicean "fathers", how confident are you, that Clement comments on every other chapter from each of Paul's epistles save 1 Corinthians, chapters 14, 15, and 16? (Did Clement perhaps also omit commentary on some other chapters, from other epistles, as well as these three from 1 Corinthians?) A related question, perhaps: if 14, 15, and 16 are fakes, how do we know, given the widespread distribution of these three chapters, for example, in our oldest extant copies of Paul's letters, P46 which Kenyon has dated to publication in the early third century, that other chapters of Paul's letters are not also fakes? In other words, what is there about Clement of Alexandria's commentary that leads you to regard his description of what Paul had written, at the same time, approximately, in the early decades of the third century, as the gold standard representing an authentic, accurate description of what Paul had written a century earlier? Why couldn't there have been fakes, as well, in Clement's possession? Finally, I must ask, though I admire this kind of research, and concur with Vorkosigan, yes, let us see more, but, should you not spell out for us, exactly what your source material for Clement's description, is based upon? If you are using a corrupt version of Clement, then, is it fair to conclude that Clement's omission of those three chapters of Paul's letter is deliberate, (he couldn't write about something invisible) and not a reflection of some subsequent intervention? Are you basing your research on Clement's original document (we know of only one extant copy, correct?), or on Cosaert's analysis, or both, or some other commentator's version of what Clement had written? In particular, how does your source material compare with the condition of P46? |
|
11-02-2011, 08:17 AM | #8 | |||||
Contributor
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: the fringe of the caribbean
Posts: 18,988
|
Quote:
Examine "The Instructor" 1.6 attributed to Clement of Alexandria. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||||
11-02-2011, 08:36 AM | #9 | |
Veteran Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: On the path of knowledge
Posts: 8,889
|
Quote:
(I have taken the obvious liberty of adjusting your format, as blocks of text often lead to the jumping to conclusions that might prove erroneous ) Reserving judgment until I have heard this entire matter through to its end. (Proverbs 18:13 ) ששבצר העברי . |
|
11-02-2011, 09:00 AM | #10 | |
Veteran Member
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Mondcivitan Republic
Posts: 2,550
|
Quote:
A thorough examination of the textual evidence for a 14, a 15 and a 16 chapter version floating about, takes up the first 35 pages. There should be threads about this in the archives, as it was kicked about by Ben C Smith (PBUH) and Andrew Criddle, as well as others, about 2 years ago. DCH (Lunch break, boss) |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|