FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Archives > Religion (Closed) > Biblical Criticism & History
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Today at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 12-11-2003, 02:04 PM   #1
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Washington, DC
Posts: 249
Default Baby Jesus: Saviour or extraterrestrial killing machine?

Just in time for Xmas, here's a repost of a little essay I wrote a couple years ago, in which I cobbled together a biography of Jesus out of the New Testament Gospels and early Christian pseudo-Gospels, and then analyzed the results as though it were a sci-fi/fantasy/horror story. The weird thing is, I think there's a more coherent and uplifting moral in my sci-fi version than in the standard Christian account. Enjoy!


Well-read Protestants know that the Roman Catholic version of the Bible is 14 books longer than the editions that all those schismatic Christians use. These 14 books, which the RCC takes to be part of the canonical Old Testament, are collectively termed The Apocrypha. (One of the best-known of these Apocryphal works is the Book of Judith, whose deadly she-mantis stunt with poor old Holofernes would inspire countless Western painters, including Gustav "Your wife was just showing us her..." Klimt.)

Anyway, there's a whole 'nother set of Apocryphal books -- those that even the Catholic Church rejects as authentic. Some of these works are disqualified from the Canon because textual and manuscript evidence proves that they were written many hundreds of years after the time when the Son of God allegedly beamed down to Earth and became flesh. Others, like the two Gospels of the Infancy, were ruled out because -- well, they seem so weird.

For instance, the Arabic Gospel of the Infancy of the Saviour has an account of a guy who got turned into a mule by a wicked witch, until Mary and Jesus come truckin' up and change him back. And Thomas the Israelite's account of Jesus's childhood makes the kid sound like one of the extraterrestrial changelings from The Village of the Damned!

It's no wonder, then, that Christians don't accept these ''Infancy Gospels'' as authentically inspired. But in a way, that's too bad -- because on a closer reading, it becomes evident why anonymous writers of the early Church felt it necessary to flesh out the missing years of Jesus' biography in the New Testament. In fact, the authors of these Apocryphal works showed such remarkable insight into the human condition that if I weren't an atheist, I'd be inclined to accept these books (in conjunction with the four canonical Gospels) as divinely inspired. But don't take my word for it; here, judge for yourself...

Okay, let's put JC's life story in rough sequence, based on New Testament and those Apocryphal accounts:

1. He's a totally adorable baby whom people shower with presents (Matt. 2:11) and whose used diapers even have magical healing powers! (Arab. Ch. 11)

2. When he's a little older, we get to see Li'l Jesus® hanging out with Muppet Babies versions of his future Apostles and other Gospel characters, like Li'l Judas™ and Li'l Simon the Canaanite™. (Arab. Ch. 35) Unfortunately, Li'l Jesus has turned into a complete shit and goes around putting the hoodoo on people for the most trivial offenses, like when a Li'l Pharisee stomps on this clay fish-pond that Jesus made as an Arts 'n' Crafts project. (Thom. Lat. Ch. 4) Plus, he sasses back to his teacher, and then promptly makes the poor man shrivel up and die when the dude tries to apply a little discipline. Joseph, ever the sharp one, comments to Mary, "Do not let him go outside of the door, because those that make him angry die" (Thom. Gk 1. Ch. 14), thereby revealing this to be a very early draft of that Twilight Zone story about the kid who would wish people into the cornfield. But when his mom and dad call him on it, he finally relents and undoes all his dark magic (Thom. Lat. Ch. 6), which is almost exactly what happens in Joe Dante's happy-ending remake of "It's a Good Life" in the 1983 movie version!

3. Later, he's nicer to the teachers (even though they're confused by this gifted-track student), but a bit sassy to his parents when they come a-lookin' for him (Luke 2:43-49)

4. Fast-forward a few years, and he's using his powers for fun things like turning water into wine for the wedding at Cana. He's rude to Mary again, though. (John 2:1-11)

5. The guy just gets nicer and nicer, healing people left and right and interceding when some folks are about to throw rocks at a hooker (John 8 3:7). He still slips up now and then, however, as when he utters a racist slur to a Syrophoenician woman who wants him to help her. Rather than acting all put-upon, though, she snaps back with a bit of wordplay, and Jesus is so impressed at her insight and faith that he sends some good magic her way after all (Mark 7:25-30)

6. Jesus cashes in the last of his magic to help other people even though this particular spell requires the loss of his own life (Luke 23:37), and -- unlike the little boy who thoughtlessly zapped his playmates if they so much as looked at him funny -- he's a total mensch about it at age 33. The guy even has the class to say "Forgive them, father, they know not what they do" (Luke 23:34), as well he should, since he himself used to screw up back when he didn't know any better.

In other words, when the canonical and apocryphal Gospels are taken together, the entire life of Jesus becomes an allegory about the importance of developing moral wisdom: for even the incarnation of God Himself behaved like a monster when he was too immature to know better. The take-home message, then, is: "Everyone, let's all learn to grow the fuck up and always use our God-given talents to make other people's lives better, not worse, Amen."

Amen.
Throbert McGee is offline  
Old 12-11-2003, 05:49 PM   #2
Contributor
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Los Angeles area
Posts: 40,549
Default

Hm - this idea seems to be common.

Interview with Jack Black

Quote:
JB: It's the landmark year. I'm a Jew. Thirty-three is when Christ died. So though I'm a Jew, in the back of my mind I still think that I gotta get it done before I'm thirty-four because well, I don't know why. He got it done before He was thirty-four.

DH: It seems like he had plans to do a few other things.

JB: Oh really? [laughs] Is there evidence of that?

DH: He just seems like the kind of guy bent on remaking the world.

JB: He had superpowers and that's the main reason I like Him. Anyone who can float, has power of levitation, or can shoot lasers out of his eyes...

DH: I don't remember hearing about the laser thing with Jesus.

JB: Well, how do you think he turned the water into wine? With His eye-lasers.

DH: [laughing] I see. I think your Jewish education is shining right through. I don't feel like I'm talking to a well-versed Christian.

JB: It would be cool if Jesus were a comic book character and could fight against other superheroes like Superman or Aquaman.

DH: Right.

JB: They did do that thing on South Park. Their pilot episode was Jesus vs. Santa Claus. That was pretty good.

DH: You sort of made fun of Jesus in a Mr. Show episode...

JB: Oh. Jeepers Creepers Semi-Star?

DH: Yeah.

JB: Kind of. Yeah.

DH: Did you receive any flack for your religious...

JB: Zero flack. Me personally, I don't have anything against Jesus any more than I do any of the religious icons. I think they're all pretty funny. Buddha is pretty funny. Buddha is the coolest, though. If I had to go with one, I'd probably party with the Buddha.

DH: Have you noticed that, more and more, next to the Bible in hotels is the book of Buddha?

JB: No.

DH: Yeah. Next time you're put up in a fancy-pants hotel someplace, particularly a slick, modern one... like the Mondrian.

JB: Well, of course the Mondrian.

DH: It's pretty interesting because you assume that the Bible is left in the hotel room for the three a.m. of the soul. Like the, "Someone help me." Whenever I've opened a Bible at random it's just sort of gobbledygook, but when I've opened the Buddha book at random it's actually incredibly soothing, sort of general remarks.
Toto is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:06 PM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.