mudknot2005

Considering he impregnated a women out of wedlock?

Mace

What the fuck are you talking about? "God" is not a he. God is a goddess of the moon whom we give thanks to when the corn is reaped fully each passing year.

All kidding aside, I'd say "yes" to your question. In the Biblical sense, of course.

Toto

This is E material.

mudknot2005

you forgot about us dancing naked.............okay... since "god" impregnated... ect...

Beastt

I suppose the obvious argument would be that in the religious sense, a marriage is the joining of two, into one, before God. So in that sense, God could impregnate anyone and not technically be other than married to them.

The obvious question for me is; Did Mary know what was going on? If she didn't know then she couldn't provide her consent and without consent, we have the technical aspects of sexual assault.

Of course for any of this to be true God must first exist. And in my opinion, that's where the whole scenario breaks down.

mudknot2005

this is true, i was mearly trying to poke fun at it....... Basically same thing as saying god commited a sin by being crucifed because by placing himself on earth and knowing he was going to be killed was a form of suicide....

Beastt

Or that it was wrong of Adam and Eve to disobey God when God had purposely kept them from understanding right and wrong.

Horse's Gullet

He obviously gave her enough sense to realize right from wrong, or she wouldn't have been discussing the situation to begin with.

Ophis

There wasn't much of a discussion there. The serpent asked about God's prohibition, and Eve replied. The serpent then said that God was lying, and Eve ate the fruit, no questions asked. There's absolutely no sign of a knowledge of right and wrong there.

There's also the fact that the main reason for Eve taking the fruit was to gain a knowledge of good and evil. Rather pointless for someone who already knows.

Also, you seem to be ignoring Genesis 3:7 and 3:22, which show that Adam and Eve did not originally have a knowledge of good and evil, but gained that knowledge after eating the fruit.

Beastt

Well, as Ophis already pointed out, it really doesn't matter whether you believe Eve had knowledge of right and wrong before eating the apple. If she did, then it's a bit difficult to believe that she was ignorant of right and wrong. If she didn't, then you can't expect her to know any better.

Either way the story fails.