FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Elsewhere > ~Elsewhere~
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Yesterday at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 09-30-2003, 04:49 PM   #111
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Orions Belt
Posts: 3,911
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by Corona688 Plus the bikers are just scary.
Ah, C'mon. All the biker babes think I look really cute in my chaps (and bluejeans).
Kosh is offline  
Old 09-30-2003, 06:05 PM   #112
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: middle earth
Posts: 601
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by HelenM
I didn't say anything about you being the only one who has had experiences of God. Your response is not relevant to my comment even though you posted it after my comment, as if it was connected with it. When you respond this way people do get confused.
I am confused about the relavance of why you keep telling me my comments are not relevant since that is the reason why I have been relagated to this area the Elsewhere~ section. Don't you think you are taking a BIG risk by being here and making all your comments irrelevant as well?

Quote:
I was responding to what you wrote yesterday - would you read it again? Here it is: [b] hd:I think I am being unjustly picked on here. Yes lets all pick on the Christian.[b]

Did you forget you wrote about being picked on, just yesterday?
Well I do believe menopause affects the memory. I didn't really feel picked on. Singled out maybe. Everyone thinks because you are a Christian you should be able to explain deep and profound questions that trouble us all. I tell you Helen there are many things I do not know like: how is my situation going to end. I don't have a clue but I trust God to pull me through it and He will put my enemies to shame. Read the 71 Psalm. This is an excellent Psalm.

Quote:
Anyway, I'm glad if you don't feel that way any more
I have found infidels probably the best site so far with the exception of Heart light. I just have to really get my feet wet. It must be the hospital experience Helen that I had. This was the injustice not you guys here in cyber space.

Quote:
whole yes I am, thanks
Thanks Helen

Quote:
your husband did show up, hd.

take care & God bless,
Helen
Thanks he did show up but the session did not go well and I just can't forgive what he did by having the EMTs and police harrassing me and all that went on. He was the one who wanted to drive me to the brink of insanity. Now he tells me he loves me and does not want a divorce. My trust of him is gone totally. I can not live with him with the way things are. I feel betwixt and between. Look Mommy I am airing dirty laundry God my mother was a good woman.
hope's daughter is offline  
Old 09-30-2003, 06:37 PM   #113
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Ill
Posts: 6,577
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by hope's daughter
I am confused about the relavance of why you keep telling me my comments are not relevant since that is the reason why I have been relagated to this area the Elsewhere~ section. Don't you think you are taking a BIG risk by being here and making all your comments irrelevant as well?
But there are two kinds of irrelevance. This thread was moved here because posts in it weren't relevant to the topic of the forum it was in.

I was pointing out that your comments weren't relevant to other responses in the thread, which makes them confusing to people. I'm saying this because you've asked a few times whether your thoughts are clear and focused. Posting comments which aren't relevant to the rest of the thread indicates you do have a problem with focus, sometimes. I've tried to give you examples rather than simply suggest you might have a focus problem without explaining why I think so - which I think would be unfair and disrespectful, so I try not to do such things.

Quote:
Well I do believe menopause affects the memory. I didn't really feel picked on. Singled out maybe. Everyone thinks because you are a Christian you should be able to explain deep and profound questions that trouble us all. I tell you Helen there are many things I do not know like: how is my situation going to end. I don't have a clue but I trust God to pull me through it and He will put my enemies to shame. Read the 71 Psalm. This is an excellent Psalm.
I just looked that up - yes, that's a good one

Quote:


I have found infidels probably the best site so far with the exception of Heart light. I just have to really get my feet wet. It must be the hospital experience Helen that I had. This was the injustice not you guys here in cyber space.
I'm confused - what do you mean by "it must be the hospital experience I had?"

Quote:
Thanks he did show up but the session did not go well and I just can't forgive what he did by having the EMTs and police harrassing me and all that went on. He was the one who wanted to drive me to the brink of insanity. Now he tells me he loves me and does not want a divorce.
Do you believe him?

I know it's hard to forgive, but didn't Jesus say that unless we forgive others, God won't forgive us? My pastor preached a whole sermon series on forgiveness a few months ago. You can find it here if you're interested.

Quote:
My trust of him is gone totally. I can not live with him with the way things are. I feel betwixt and between. Look Mommy I am airing dirty laundry God my mother was a good woman.
It is very hard to trust people who take your rights away. I know But maybe he really does love you and is trying to do what he thinks is best for you.

Did you think the counselor was fair? Did he take your husband's side? Who chose your counselor? Is he/she a Christian?

Helen
HelenM is offline  
Old 09-30-2003, 07:53 PM   #114
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: sugar factory
Posts: 873
Default

Quote:
Bring to a shameful end those who attack me; Cover with contempt and scorn those who seek my ruin
psalm 71 is brilliant. but which two faced prick wrote this bit? and for what purpose?
sweep is offline  
Old 09-30-2003, 08:25 PM   #115
Contributor
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Posts: 15,576
Default Still missing what your aim is to achieve

Quote:
Originally posted by hope's daughter

This is only one experience among many that I could captivate your attention with. I do not normally share these personal experiences with anyone since a lot of times you get a knee jerk reaction like, "Yeah right." There is a God and He is knowable because He created the Universe so when we study the universe we are studying how God thinks. When we study the Bible we are coming to know Him through His word. So when He reaches out to you, you are truly amazed 1.because you don't expect it and 2. You are caught off guard 3. you find out that there really is a God and He is interested in you. This can happen to any one so please do not give up hope. Pray yes pray and call out to God and you will find you will not be disappointed. Tonight when I go to sleep again I will pray for you.
I could give you some interesting experiences as well, however I'm failing to see what informing us of your experiences does, except tell us more about you as a person, which is fine. If your goal is to make an assertion for the validity of the Godforce you embrace, then you're offering a malfunctioning piece of evidence. I was still waiting to hear about the objective parts...As I said earlier, what gives your specific example any creedance over the myriad of other operating personal experiences people have encountered for millenia?
Soul Invictus is offline  
Old 09-30-2003, 08:28 PM   #116
Contributor
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Posts: 15,576
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by hope's daughter
Joel how do I know what you have typed is truth? It is rather fancy and alot of times I take people at their word. I do know this that in Samuel it speaks about the bronze age and the Philistines and the Israelites getting weapons from them. I also know bronze is before iron but whether you speak truth or even exist I have no way of knowing. You could be some ghost.
For starters you could research to see if what he said is fallacious. The people on this board are good at that by keeping you honest, on the intellectual integrity bit!
Soul Invictus is offline  
Old 09-30-2003, 08:58 PM   #117
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: middle earth
Posts: 601
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by Corona688
Yes. That is the problem. Would you walk into a synogogue and eat bacon? Would you walk into your church and burn a cross? Would you walk into a biker bar and say 'harley davidson sucks'? No, you would not, because the bikers, christians, and jews would find these acts pointlessly offensive. Plus the bikers are just scary.

Giving emotional "arguments" like 'I'll pray for you', 'I just know god exists', 'god is watching you', 'god exists because he did x for me', 'god answers my prayers' and such isn't helping you or us. It is pointlessly offensive, looks smug and arrogant, doesn't convince anyone, is AGAINST THE RULES, and is just about the best thread-derailing weapon you could deploy on this board. ( anarchism seems to be the other. )

Corona688,

Why do you keep winking at me? Is that a sarcastic wink? Or is it meant to be friendly? I want everything I say and write to you to be filled with the love of God towards you so even if you see this guy----> you will know it is playful and fun and comes from a good heart. I find it very hard sometimes to defend my faith because athiests, agnostics and skeptics come up with some very good questions and as I told Helen I was taken to the hospital and involuntarily detained because my husband had me labeled as bipolar in '90. I could explain the whole situation to you but I do not want this all over the internet I think I have said enough about it. So what I have told you here you might just chalk it up to insanity or bipolarness or whatever. I find God does inject a certain amount of doubt into situations and this is good because you have to trust in HIM if you want your situation to improve. So if you believe in prayer as an atheist, I will take it despite the fact you may doubt the One with Whom you pray to.
hope's daughter is offline  
Old 09-30-2003, 09:00 PM   #118
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: middle earth
Posts: 601
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by Soul Invictus
For starters you could research to see if what he said is fallacious. The people on this board are good at that by keeping you honest, on the intellectual integrity bit!
I liked what you wrote. Thanks for the honesty.
hope's daughter is offline  
Old 09-30-2003, 09:32 PM   #119
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: middle earth
Posts: 601
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by HelenM
But there are two kinds of irrelevance. This thread was moved here because posts in it weren't relevant to the topic of the forum it was in.
I don't mind really Helen. The accident I had well I had a head injury. I met a man at the hospital in psyche ward named Benjamin Lawson (My sons first name is Benjamin). Well I hired him as my body guard. Silly I know but that was why I was afraid from the 11th of August to the 26th of August because my husband was threatening me with hospitalization. I was scared of him doing it. I did nothing wrong Helen to deserve this. I got fed up with the mental abuse and him giving me orders and treating me with contempt and he rewarded me with harassment and hospitalization. So I told this to Ben. He told me about how his wife has a child but not by him and then he told me of an accident where he had a head injury. Uncanniness I guess. He is just a friend and told me because I was afraid of my husband I could call him any time and he would show up. My husband is no longer living at my home but my kids are. I don't know Helen if these things can be fixed as I believe I was misdiagnosed. What I have written here Helen is really irrelevant to your sentences but things I wished you to personally know.

Quote:
I was pointing out that your comments weren't relevant to other responses in the thread, which makes them confusing to people. I'm saying this because you've asked a few times whether your thoughts are clear and focused. Posting comments which aren't relevant to the rest of the thread indicates you do have a problem with focus, sometimes. I've tried to give you examples rather than simply suggest you might have a focus problem without explaining why I think so - which I think would be unfair and disrespectful, so I try not to do such things.
Helen I will not dispute you. There are times I will read a posts by someone (not naming names) and think to myself that came from out of left field. I guess if that is the case you should ask the person why they wrote it and then see if there is a good reason and if the reason ties in. Does this make sense? Not everyone thinks alike and so to be opened minded means just that. I don't remember asking if my thoughts are clear and focus. I am pretty sure they are. I go back and read things I write and I agree with me so I see no problems. I have three that witness to me: me, myself and I. *I* is the bold one of the bunch. He is also the focuser. yes helen *I* is the masculine part of me and myself.

Quote:
I just looked that up - yes, that's a good one
Yes it is Helen and boy in the coming days am I going to be focusing on it. Matter of fact is there a plcae where Scripture can be discussed and written straight from the Bible here?

Quote:
m confused - what do you mean by "it must be the hospital experience I had?"
I think I explained it above.

Quote:
Do you believe him?
No. No I don't. The reason I was put in the hospital is to keep me from seeking a divorce from him because I got so fed up. I asked him to work on our marriage and he made it an issue of my illness. Like he is peachy clean and I am nuts. I just want out. BTW he married me Helen. If I am nuts what does that say about him?

[QUOTE}I know it's hard to forgive, but didn't Jesus say that unless we forgive others, God won't forgive us? My pastor preached a whole sermon series on forgiveness a few months ago. You can find it here if you're interested.[/QUOTE]

Yes I agree but doesn't love have to be moral to be love? I can't live with someone who is mentally abusive any more. I am tired of playing head games and if truth be known he abandoned our relationship years ago. I don't even know how to fix his problems. I want to work on my own. See I want to take responsability for me but I can not take on his burdens

Quote:
It is very hard to trust people who take your rights away. I know But maybe he really does love you and is trying to do what he thinks is best for you.
Love is not controlling and manipulation. I am his wife for goodness sakes but he treats me like I am apart of the furniture of the house. This is not love. I am tired of dealing with it and I am suppose to be the sick one.

Quote:
Did you think the counselor was fair? Did he take your husband's side? Who chose your counselor? Is he/she a Christian?
Our first counselor was fair and I liked very much, but unexpectedly, he had to move. Our present counselor is a woman and she took his side because I am the nutso one. Hell, I even have the appropriate hat to go along with my now nutso look. Yeah Helen, I wear it where ever I am. Get comments on it that it is cute. I was the one, to my husband surprise, who put the ball in roll. He the next day after we saw the counselor for the first time called the EMTS and police. Coincedence? Not on your life. He meant to do it.
hope's daughter is offline  
Old 10-01-2003, 03:17 AM   #120
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: the reliquary of Ockham's razor
Posts: 4,035
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by hope's daughter
Yes it is Helen and boy in the coming days am I going to be focusing on it. Matter of fact is there a plcae where Scripture can be discussed and written straight from the Bible here?
[/B]
hope's daughter,

I would like to clear up some things about the "relevance zone" of our different fora. We actually try to cover about everything about religion plus a lot that anybody wants to talk about like music and politics. Here is the breakdown:

"Philosophy
Philosophical discussions for people who think hard."

Philosophy in the sense that Plato, Aristotle, Kant, and Russell did philosophy. This forum overlaps with many others that are more specific--Existence of God(s) for natural theology, for example, and the philosophical merits of proofs of God. Insofar as philosophy is concerned with history and science, it would overlap with the next three, but mostly very abstract discussion of history and science would be posted in Philosophy. Next to EoG, "Moral Foundations and Principles" most frequently overlaps, because ethics is a large subfield of philosophy. "Non-Abrahamic Religion & Philosophy" is for Eastern philosophy mostly. "General Religious Discussions" would include philosophy of religion sometimes. Basically, if it is secular and non-ethical philosophy, it definitely belongs there. Bible quotes discouraged.

Existence of God(s)
Mostly for discussing various ways to prove or disprove various deities. Don't quote the Bible unless you can make a syllogism from that to the existence of God--or for an attribute of BibleGod that you want to disprove.

Biblical Criticism & History
OK, this is my baby. There is a whole subculture of Christians, Jews, Muslims, and Western atheists that this forum caters to--they are scholar wanna-bes or just people who are interested in what the professors are saying about the ancient texts. Strictly devotional threads like "how I read the Sermon on the Mount and found out that Jesus loves me and wants me to love everybody else too, isn't that neat" would be frowned upon by me. If you could tell me something about how the Sermon is different in the Gospels of Matthew and Luke, how the concepts parallel those in Stoicism or Cynicism or the Old Testament, how the text was read and used by the Church Fathers, what literary devices are employed to make an effective impression, or something like that--then I will be riveted and enthralled. We also talk about all history concerning religion in the West, and Islam too. Biblical quotes are encouraged--but not as something that we all agree upon as God's Literal Plenary-Inspired Word--though this is something you [i]can[/b] believe--but for understanding what the men (and women) who wrote it were thinking.

Evolution/Creation
The origins and diversity of life--divine fiat or product of natural forces?--and the sociopolitical ramifications of the answer.

My understanding is that the moderators here don't want Bible quotes--they want science and maybe an understanding of how science disproving Genesis impacts our world. You can argue for Intelligent Design if you are a bio buff.

Science & Skepticism
General discussions of science, skepticism, and how they relate to one another.

Good if you like string theory, the metabolism of cro magnon man, and stuff like that. Bible quotes are usually irrelevant.

Moral Foundations & Principles
Morality, immorality, subjectivism, objectivism, social contracts--what does it all mean? What is the source of morality? Discuss all aspects of secular and theistic moral systems.

If you think the Bible is an absolute guide to morality, people here would be happy to argue with you. But you would have to argue. So the relationship of the Bible to morality can be discussed.

Church–State Separation & Secular Activism
Discuss church-state separation and other topics on secular activism.

We talk about how teachers shouldn't preach from the Bible before class, etc.

Non-Abrahamic Religion & Philosophy
Discuss those worldviews that are based upon a religious and/or philosophical point of view other than a Western, Christian, Islamic, and/or a Jewish one.

You can compare the Bible to the Bhagavad Gita if you like.

General Religious Discussions
Discuss anything about religion, or lack of religion, which doesn't fit within any of our other II forums.

hope's daughter, consider this your new home. This is where you can talk about your personal experience of God, how Christians and infidels compare, how you love a certain bible passage (be prepared for snickering), and basically anything that doesn't fit in our more technical "Upper Forums."

II Formal Debates

You can watch these if you want, or if you have guts go for the glory!

II Secular Community Forums

Bible quotes a no no. This is for atheist-friendly conversation.

Media & Popular Culture
A discussion area for all manner of "popular culture" items, such as books, movies, television, etc.

You understand this.

Political Discussions
Discuss all manner of political things here!

Religion only as it relates to governmental type politics.

Freethought Humor, Jokes, Etc.
Christians and other theists be warned: what we find to be funny may be in extremely bad taste or even very offensive to you!

I think you have a sense of humor, but you don't like foul language, so avoid!

~~Elsewhere~~
This forum is solely for topics moved from other forums due to a lack of serious content. No new threads are allowed.

This is just for threads that get moved. They are moved because (1) they have gotten off the topic for the forum theme (like archaeology in this case) or (2) they have gotten too silly, rancorous, or personal (which may also apply here).

In short, General Religious Discussions are your friend. If you have a hard time understanding/accepting what Joel posted, it may not be your cup of tea to post in BC&H.

best,
Peter Kirby
Peter Kirby is online now   Edit/Delete Message
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:35 AM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.