Agnostic Theist

As a treat for you all (because I know you'll be jacking off at the very concept of evaluating this stuff), I have found a debate between the apostle Peter and quasi-gnostic magician Simon Magus (did you know that the etymon of magic is indeed the greek word 'magos', which itself is derived from the Opersian word 'Magus', meaning 'magician'?)

If you were in this debate, how would you argue?