FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Archives > Religion (Closed) > Biblical Criticism & History
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Today at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 09-20-2011, 12:12 PM   #1
Contributor
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Los Angeles area
Posts: 40,549
Default Enter to win books on Historical Jesus

Giveaway

Enter before October 8 to win a Baker Academic Historical Jesus Book Package (retail at $180)! including

A Hitchhiker’s Guide to Jesus (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Bruce N. Fisk
"a fresh and imaginative approach to Jesus studies and biblical criticism, providing a gripping fictional account of one student’s journey to the Middle East to investigate the New Testament and the life of Jesus for himself."

Constructing Jesus (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Dale C. Allison Jr.

The Christ of the Miracle Stories (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Wendy J. Cotter

Jesus Among Friends and Enemies (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Chris Keith and Larry Hurtado

Jesus and Scripture (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Steve Moyise

Are You the One Who Is to Come? (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Michael F. Bird
Toto is offline  
Old 09-20-2011, 01:52 PM   #2
Contributor
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: the fringe of the caribbean
Posts: 18,988
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Toto View Post
Giveaway

Enter before October 8 to win a Baker Academic Historical Jesus Book Package (retail at $180)! including

A Hitchhiker’s Guide to Jesus (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Bruce N. Fisk
"a fresh and imaginative approach to Jesus studies and biblical criticism, providing a gripping fictional account of one student’s journey to the Middle East to investigate the New Testament and the life of Jesus for himself."

Constructing Jesus (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Dale C. Allison Jr.

The Christ of the Miracle Stories (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Wendy J. Cotter

Jesus Among Friends and Enemies (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Chris Keith and Larry Hurtado

Jesus and Scripture (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Steve Moyise

Are You the One Who Is to Come? (or via: amazon.co.uk) by Michael F. Bird

Who wants another FICTIONAL account?

Quote:
......a gripping fictional account of one student’s journey to the Middle East to investigate the New Testament and the life of Jesus for himself."...
aa5874 is offline  
Old 09-21-2011, 05:35 PM   #3
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: The Horror! The Horror!
Posts: 4,367
Default

Sorry, you'd have to pay me to take those books. Pay me quite a bit. Coupons will not do.

Maybe I'd read, 'Deconstructing Jesus'?
dendrast is offline  
Old 09-22-2011, 09:06 PM   #4
Contributor
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: MT
Posts: 10,656
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by dendrast View Post
Sorry, you'd have to pay me to take those books. Pay me quite a bit. Coupons will not do.

Maybe I'd read, 'Deconstructing Jesus'?
You are not alone in that way of thinking. A book with the title, Deconstructing Jesus, is actually a favorite book among the Jesus minimalists. It is all about promoting uncertainty about the historical Jesus, and I am sure you would love it. I think it is unfortunate, though. This point is often neglected among those with a mentality of opposition, but the best criticisms supply better much better explanations for the data in question, and Dale Allison's Constructing Jesus: Memory, Imagination, and History is highly reputed among critical scholars of New Testament history for that reason.
ApostateAbe is offline  
Old 09-22-2011, 10:15 PM   #5
Contributor
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Los Angeles area
Posts: 40,549
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ApostateAbe View Post
.... This point is often neglected among those with a mentality of opposition, but the best criticisms supply better much better explanations for the data in question, and Dale Allison's Constructing Jesus: Memory, Imagination, and History is highly reputed among critical scholars of New Testament history for that reason.
I got a different impression from this previous thread on Dale Allison's Constructing Jesus
Toto is offline  
Old 09-23-2011, 04:49 AM   #6
Contributor
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: MT
Posts: 10,656
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Toto View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by ApostateAbe View Post
.... This point is often neglected among those with a mentality of opposition, but the best criticisms supply better much better explanations for the data in question, and Dale Allison's Constructing Jesus: Memory, Imagination, and History is highly reputed among critical scholars of New Testament history for that reason.
I got a different impression from this previous thread on Dale Allison's Constructing Jesus
Yeah, I think Steven Carr's reaction is characteristic. Pointing and laughing at the best explanations for the data is taken as preferable to explaining the data.
ApostateAbe is offline  
Old 09-23-2011, 07:57 AM   #7
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: England
Posts: 5,629
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ApostateAbe View Post

Yeah, I think Steven Carr's reaction is characteristic. Pointing and laughing at the best explanations for the data is taken as preferable to explaining the data.
What's wrong with pointing and laughing ,when I have been trained as a scientist to evaluate arguments and look for evidence-based judgements?

I remember reading McGrath's review of Allison's book - 'Even fabricated material may provide a true sense of the gist of what Jesus was about, however inauthentic it may be as far as the specific details are concerned.'

Allison writes in his book 'All this is why fictions may contain facts; an accurate impression can take any number of forms. Even a work as full of make-believe as the Alexander Romance sometimes catches the character of the historical Alexander of Macedon. Similarly, tales about an absentminded professor may be apocryphal and yet spot-on because they capture the teacher’s personality. The letter can be false, the spirit true.'

Just how much does the word 'fictions' mean to you? Is it a word that you are likely to confuse with 'facts'?

Do you think real scholars work with facts or with fictions?


Allison also writes 'I can think of no line of reasoning that is not, in the end, strictly circular.'

So circular reasoning based on fiction, and you insist that the naughty boys stop laughing at this, because a good boy wouldn't point and laugh?
Steven Carr is offline  
Old 09-23-2011, 11:08 AM   #8
Contributor
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: MT
Posts: 10,656
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Steven Carr View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by ApostateAbe View Post

Yeah, I think Steven Carr's reaction is characteristic. Pointing and laughing at the best explanations for the data is taken as preferable to explaining the data.
What's wrong with pointing and laughing ,when I have been trained as a scientist to evaluate arguments and look for evidence-based judgements?

I remember reading McGrath's review of Allison's book - 'Even fabricated material may provide a true sense of the gist of what Jesus was about, however inauthentic it may be as far as the specific details are concerned.'

Allison writes in his book 'All this is why fictions may contain facts; an accurate impression can take any number of forms. Even a work as full of make-believe as the Alexander Romance sometimes catches the character of the historical Alexander of Macedon. Similarly, tales about an absentminded professor may be apocryphal and yet spot-on because they capture the teacher’s personality. The letter can be false, the spirit true.'

Just how much does the word 'fictions' mean to you? Is it a word that you are likely to confuse with 'facts'?

Do you think real scholars work with facts or with fictions?


Allison also writes 'I can think of no line of reasoning that is not, in the end, strictly circular.'

So circular reasoning based on fiction, and you insist that the naughty boys stop laughing at this, because a good boy wouldn't point and laugh?
I really do think that legitimate historical knowledge can be inferred from fictional stories. Suppose that all we knew about the people of 18th century England was Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice--I think you would agree that quite a few legitimate historical conclusions can be inferred from it, but it does not follow that you are conflating fact with fiction. Not that I think that the Christian texts are fictions (they are more like religious myths), but, I think even fictional material can provide an abundance of historical knowledge, the same as with religious myths. The point is to explain the data. If you can't explain the data with as nearly as much probability as your opponent, then you can point and laugh, but I think the joke is on you. You need to better explain the data. I am pretty sure that is the way it works in the sciences, also.
ApostateAbe is offline  
Old 09-23-2011, 11:40 AM   #9
Contributor
 
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Los Angeles area
Posts: 40,549
Default

Nice example.

Pride_and_Prejudice
Quote:
Pride and Prejudice is a novel by Jane Austen, first published in 1813. The story follows the main character Elizabeth Bennet as she deals with issues of manners, upbringing, morality, education and marriage in the society of the landed gentry of early 19th-century England. Elizabeth is the second of five daughters of a country gentleman, living near the fictional town of Meryton in Hertfordshire, near London.
One could learn a lot of accurate historical information from a novel, but it would not include the historical Elizabeth Bennet or the location of Meryton.

Allison and McGrath only make sense once you realize that they assume the existence of the historical Jesus, and are using the gospels to provide background details.
Toto is offline  
Old 09-23-2011, 11:58 AM   #10
Contributor
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: MT
Posts: 10,656
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Toto View Post
Nice example.

Pride_and_Prejudice
Quote:
Pride and Prejudice is a novel by Jane Austen, first published in 1813. The story follows the main character Elizabeth Bennet as she deals with issues of manners, upbringing, morality, education and marriage in the society of the landed gentry of early 19th-century England. Elizabeth is the second of five daughters of a country gentleman, living near the fictional town of Meryton in Hertfordshire, near London.
One could learn a lot of accurate historical information from a novel, but it would not include the historical Elizabeth Bennet or the location of Meryton.

Allison and McGrath only make sense once you realize that they assume the existence of the historical Jesus, and are using the gospels to provide background details.
OK. We are in agreement, at least, that we are not conflating fact with fiction if we choose to infer historical facts from a work of fiction, and that goes to the topic of disagreement between Steven Carr and me. And I agree that you really wouldn't be able to rightfully infer the conclusion that Mr. Darcy existed based on the novel alone. In the case of the gospels, the best explanation for the contents of the texts entails the conclusion that Jesus existed as a historical human, so it is not assumed, but it is inferred. If you can explain Jesus of the gospels the same as you can explain Mr. Darcy of Pride and Prejudice, with more probability than scholars, then you win.
ApostateAbe is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:16 PM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.