Freethought & Rationalism ArchiveThe archives are read only. |
12-17-2003, 05:07 PM | #1 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: voston
Posts: 699
|
Altering the Bible - part one
Altering the Bible - part one
by Mr. TrrueIslam "Do you then hope that they would believe in you, and a party from among them (Jews) indeed used to hear the world of Allah, then altered it after they had understood it, and they know this. "Holy Qur'an 2:75. The Holy Qur'an accuses the Jews of altering the scriptures of God. Far from being Islamic "anti-Semitism," this fact is a matter of recorded history. John N. Hayes, professor of Old Testament at Candler School of Theology, Emory University, in this book "An Introduction to Old Testament Study", observes, "Rabbinical references provide evidence that the pre-Masoretic scribes not only guarded and preserved the text but at time WENT SO FAR AS TO ALTER THE TEXT ITSELF." (33) Toy, in Judaism and Christianity, says also, Transcripts were copied and recopied by scribes who not only sometimes made errors in the letters of the words, but permitted themselves to introduce new material into the text." The alterations made by the Jewish scribes, called tiqqune sopherim or "emendations of the scribes," were not random or casual but were calculated with a specific goal. Hayes observes: "Manyof the changes assumed seem to have the purpose of making the text more theologically acceptable by changing expressions which seem to lack proper reverence. Some examples." Gen 18:22 originally read' YHWH still stood before Abraham rather than `Abraham still stood before YHWH', II Sam 20:1 read `to his gods' rather than `to his tents'; Ez 18: 17 read `my God's nose' rather than `their nose'; and Job 32:3 read `they condemned God' rather than `they condemned Job'" (34) These "emendations of the scribes" were made to conceal the true reality God. As shown, the God of the Old Testament was a so-called anthropomorphic God-a Man. The Jewish scribes corrupted the scripture in an attempt to hide the fact. E.O. James, in The Concept of Deity observes that, "In post exilic Judaism…efforts were made by the scribes to remove some of the more crude anthropomorphism's or to paraphrase and SPIRTUALIZE them. Thus, in the Targums the finger of God of Ex viii. 19 was rendered `this is a plague from before Yahweh' and when he was said to abide in, come to, or depart from a place, the phrase was made to read `God caused his presence (shekinto) to abide there, and the like, just as seeing God, or God manifesting Himself to man, was interpreted as the `the glory (yekara) of God.' When the earlier anthropomorphism's were retained (e.g. in references to God having eyes, ears, hands and feet) the terms `memra,'meaning the `divine self manifestation,' was introduced as a reverend circumlocution for God as active in the affairs of men. (35)" Robert Dentan, in "The Knowledge of God in Ancient Israel bares witness that "In later times…older texts were changed to modify or eliminate some of the cruder passages (of anthropomorphism)." (36) |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|