FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Archives > Religion (Closed) > Biblical Criticism & History
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Yesterday at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 12-25-2006, 10:57 PM   #1
Contributor
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Falls Creek, Oz.
Posts: 11,192
Default Register of prenicene citations re: "christianity"

Register of purported Citations and/or Correspondence
between representatives of christianity and non-
christian representatives of contemporary government
in the pre-nicene epoch (000 to 325 CE).


Can anyone think of a more concise description for
the following tabulation? Essentially all I am trying
to achieve is the indexation of citations of contact
between christianity and the external world in the
early period. (ie: I am not concerned with intra-
christian communiques, or disputes between contending
heretics and mainstreamers)

It should be noted, as was dealt with in an earlier thread,
that all citations from the first century are treated as
fraudulent, or fictitious.

COL1 = Century
COL2 = Date where known
COL3 = Description of correspondence

1st - 032 - Letter of King Agbar & Jesus' Rescript
1st - 030? - Letter from Herod Antipas
1st - 030 - letter of Publius Lentulus
1st - 032? - Letters of Caiaphas
1st - 050 - Letters of Pilate
1st - 050 - Confession of Pilate,
1st - 064 - Nero fire references (Tacit.Annals XV written 109.CE)
1st - 075 - Domitian (emp:069-079) "Persecution"
1st - 091 - Josephus Flavius (Refs in Antiquity of the Jews)

2nd - 109 - Tacitus (references in Annals XV)
2nd - 112 - Plinius, Ep 10:97 - Pliny to Trajan
2nd - 113 - Trajan to Pliny (rescript)
2nd - 115? - Trajan's order of the Martyrdom Ignatius
2nd - 135? - Hadrian Rescript to the pro-consul of Asia
2nd - 150? - Antonius Pius (emp:138-161) to the commune of Asia
2nd - 167 - M.Antonius "christian obstinacy" reference (Meditations, 11:3)
2nd - 174 - M.Antonius (Rescript?)
2nd - 174 - M.Antonius (Report to Senate re: "Thundering Legion")
2nd - 177 - Apology of Melito (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 177 - Apology of Tatian (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 177 - Apology of Athenagoras (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Apollinaris (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Theophilus (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Miltiades (to M.Antonius ?)

3rd - 202 - The "edict of Septimius Severus"
3rd - 248 - Philip Arabus, turns christian for the millenial games of Rome.
3rd - 250 - Emperor Decius - perhaps 50 executions (250/251)
3rd - 255? - Galienus' decree (via H.E.); emperor 253-258

4th - 303? -Diocletian - perhaps 50 executions
4th - 311 - The Edict of Milan (Constantine/Licinius)


Can anyone add any more?
(eg: Perhaps Celsus belongs here)
mountainman is offline  
Old 01-24-2007, 04:17 AM   #2
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Mondcivitan Republic
Posts: 2,550
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by mountainman View Post
Register of purported Citations and/or Correspondence
between representatives of christianity and non-
christian representatives of contemporary government
in the pre-nicene epoch (000 to 325 CE).


Can anyone think of a more concise description for
the following tabulation? Essentially all I am trying
to achieve is the indexation of citations of contact
between christianity and the external world in the
early period.

Can anyone add any more? (eg: Perhaps Celsus belongs here)
How about Acts? It is addressed to someone (Most Excellent Theophilus) in the form of an apology "explaining" the early history of Christianity.

It is undated, unfortunately, and we do not know who Theophilus was. As for date, I'd put it in early 2nd century, since I am inclined to agree with those who see reflections of Josephus's Antiquities (ca. 95 CE).

Dave Hindley
DCHindley is offline  
Old 01-24-2007, 05:40 AM   #3
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Australia
Posts: 5,714
Default

Lucian, around 160 CE.
GakuseiDon is offline  
Old 01-24-2007, 06:57 AM   #4
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: USA
Posts: 1,307
Default

David, are you aware that mountainman's position is that all the ante-Nicene literature was forged/interpolated by Eusebius and Lactantius?
S.C.Carlson is offline  
Old 02-07-2007, 06:02 PM   #5
Contributor
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Falls Creek, Oz.
Posts: 11,192
Default

COL1 = Century
COL2 = Date where known
COL3 = Description of correspondence

Hyperlink shows Philosopher Jay's recent article ...


1st - 032 - Letter of King Agbar & Jesus' Rescript
1st - 030? - Letter from Herod Antipas
1st - 030 - letter of Publius Lentulus
1st - 032? - Letters of Caiaphas
1st - 050 - Letters of Pilate
1st - 050 - Confession of Pilate,
1st - 064 - Nero fire references (Tacit.Annals XV written 109.CE)
1st - 075 - Domitian (emp:069-079) "Persecution"
1st - 091 - Josephus Flavius (Refs in Antiquity of the Jews)

2nd - 109 - Tacitus (references in Annals XV)
2nd - 112 - Plinius, Ep 10:97 - Pliny to Trajan
2nd - 113 - Trajan to Pliny (rescript)
2nd - 115? - Trajan's order of the Martyrdom Ignatius
2nd - 135? - Hadrian Rescript to the pro-consul of Asia
2nd - 150? - Antonius Pius (emp:138-161) to the commune of Asia
2nd - 160? - Lucian
2nd - 166 - Martydom of Justin Martyr at Rome
2nd - 167 - M.Antonius "christian obstinacy" reference (Meditations, 11:3)
2nd - 167 - Martydom of Polycarp at Smyrna
2nd - 174 - M.Antonius (Rescript?)
2nd - 174 - M.Antonius (Report to Senate re: "Thundering Legion")
2nd - 175 - Celsus
2nd - 177 - Apology of Melito (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 177 - Apology of Tatian (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 177 - Letter "Gallic christians" - Martydom of Blandina & Pothinus
2nd - 177 - Apology of Athenagoras (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Apollinaris (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Theophilus (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Miltiades (to M.Antonius ?)

3rd - 202 - The "edict of Septimius Severus"
3rd - 248 - Philip Arabus, turns christian for the millenial games of Rome.
3rd - 250 - Emperor Decius - perhaps 50 executions (250/251)
3rd - 255? - Galienus' decree (via H.E.); emperor 253-258

4th - 303? -Diocletian - perhaps 50 executions
4th - 311 - The Edict of Milan (Constantine/Licinius)
mountainman is offline  
Old 02-07-2007, 06:30 PM   #6
Contributor
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Falls Creek, Oz.
Posts: 11,192
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by S.C.Carlson View Post
David, are you aware that mountainman's position is that all the ante-Nicene literature was forged/interpolated by Eusebius and Lactantius?
Stephen, are you aware that I have assumed this position in order
to satisfy myself that it can be refuted. I dont really like the idea
any better than you, or the next person, but the logic of the
situation demands a scholarly appraisal of the possibility that our
"dear friend" Eusebius, did not report to us the facts of antiquity.
mountainman is offline  
Old 03-18-2007, 10:16 PM   #7
Contributor
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Falls Creek, Oz.
Posts: 11,192
Default

Porphyry, Mani and Dura-Europa have been added to the third century,
Celsus to the second. What other citations exist in respect to the
historical existence of "the tribe of christians" in the prenicene
epoch?


COL1 = Century
COL2 = Date where known
COL3 = Description of correspondence

Hyperlink shows Philosopher Jay's recent article ...


1st - 032 - Letter of King Agbar & Jesus' Rescript
1st - 030? - Letter from Herod Antipas
1st - 030 - letter of Publius Lentulus
1st - 032? - Letters of Caiaphas
1st - 050 - Letters of Pilate
1st - 050 - Confession of Pilate,
1st - 064 - Nero fire references (Tacit.Annals XV written 109.CE)
1st - 075 - Domitian (emp:069-079) "Persecution"
1st - 091 - Josephus Flavius (Refs in Antiquity of the Jews)

2nd - XXX - Papyrii fragments (Dated via paleography
2nd - 109 - Tacitus (references in Annals XV)
2nd - 112 - Plinius, Ep 10:97 - Pliny to Trajan
2nd - 113 - Trajan to Pliny (rescript)
2nd - 115? - Trajan's order of the Martyrdom Ignatius
2nd - 135? - Hadrian Rescript to the pro-consul of Asia
2nd - 150? - Antonius Pius (emp:138-161) to the commune of Asia
2nd - 160? - Lucian
2nd - 166 - Martydom of Justin Martyr at Rome
2nd - 167 - M.Antonius "christian obstinacy" reference (Meditations, 11:3)
2nd - 167 - Martydom of Polycarp at Smyrna
2nd - 174 - M.Antonius (Rescript?)
2nd - 174 - M.Antonius (Report to Senate re: "Thundering Legion")
2nd - 175 - Celsus
2nd - 177 - Apology of Melito (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 177 - Apology of Tatian (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 177 - Letter "Gallic christians" - Martydom of Blandina & Pothinus
2nd - 177 - Apology of Athenagoras (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Apollinaris (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Theophilus (to M.Antonius ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Miltiades (to M.Antonius ?)

3rd - 202 - The "edict of Septimius Severus"
3rd - 248 - Philip Arabus, turns christian for the millenial games of Rome.
3rd - 250 - Emperor Decius - perhaps 50 executions (250/251)
3rd - 255? - Galienus' decree (via H.E.); emperor 253-258
3rd - 258? - Dura-Europa "house church" conjecture.
3rd - 276 - Mani, the Sassanian "sage" (made to appear "christian")
3rd - 299 - Porphyry's violent anti-christian polemic

4th - 303? -Diocletian - perhaps 50 executions
4th - 311 - The Edict of Milan (Constantine/Licinius)[/QUOTE]
mountainman is offline  
Old 03-28-2007, 05:01 PM   #8
Contributor
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Falls Creek, Oz.
Posts: 11,192
Default

Citations to the existence of the Pre-Nicene "tribe of christians"
from the first three centuries. (Updated)

COL1 = Century
COL2 = Date where known
COL3 = Description of correspondence


1st - 032 - Letter of King Agbar & Jesus' Rescript
1st - 030? - Letter from Herod Antipas
1st - 030 - letter of Publius Lentulus
1st - 032? - Letters of Caiaphas
1st - 050 - Letters of Pilate
1st - 050 - Confession of Pilate,
1st - 064 - Nero fire references (Tacit.Annals XV written 109.CE)
1st - 075 - Domitian (emp:069-079) "Persecution"
1st - 091 - Josephus Flavius (Refs in Antiquity of the Jews)

2nd - XXX - Papyrii fragments (Dated via paleography
2nd - 109 - Tacitus (references in Annals XV)
2nd - 112 - Plinius, Ep 10:97 - Pliny to Trajan
2nd - 113 - Trajan to Pliny (rescript)
2nd - 115? - Trajan's order of the Martyrdom Ignatius
2nd - 135? - Hadrian Rescript to the pro-consul of Asia
2nd - 150? - Antonius Pius (emp:138-161) to the commune of Asia
2nd - 166 - Martydom of Justin Martyr at Rome
2nd - 167 - M.Antoninus "christian" ref (Med, 11:3)-INTERPOLATION
2nd - 167 - Martydom of Polycarp at Smyrna
2nd - 169 - Lucian (Life of Peregrine)
2nd - 174 - M.Antoninus (Rescript?)
2nd - 174 - M.Antoninus (Report to Senate re: "Thundering Legion")
2nd - 175 - Celsus
2nd - 177 - Apology of Melito (to M.Antoninus ?)
2nd - 177 - Apology of Tatian (to M.Antoninus ?)
2nd - 177 - Letter "Gallic christians" - Martydom of Blandina & Pothinus
2nd - 177 - Apology of Athenagoras (to M.Antoninus ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Apollinaris (to M.Antoninus ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Theophilus (to M.Antoninus ?)
2nd - 178 - Apology of Miltiades (to M.Antoninus ?)
2nd - 180? - Lucian (Alexander the Prophet)

3rd - 202 - The "edict of Septimius Severus"
3rd - 248 - Philip Arabus, turns christian for the millenial games of Rome.
3rd - 250 - Emperor Decius - perhaps 50 executions (250/251)
3rd - 255? - Galienus' decree (via H.E.); emperor 253-258
3rd - 258? - Dura-Europa "house church" conjecture.
3rd - 276 - Mani, the Sassanian "sage" (made to appear "christian")

4rd - 301 - Porphyry's violent anti-christian polemic
4th - 303? -Diocletian - perhaps 50 executions
4th - 311 - The Edict of Milan (Constantine/Licinius)
mountainman is offline  
Old 03-29-2007, 07:45 AM   #9
Contributor
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: London UK
Posts: 16,024
Default

Various letters of Paul to and from Seneca? I assume you want a list of everything including forgeries, and then we can sift those.

Does ECW cover this?

Edict of Milan is about religious tolerance - does it mention xianity?
Clivedurdle is offline  
Old 03-29-2007, 07:48 PM   #10
Contributor
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Falls Creek, Oz.
Posts: 11,192
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Clivedurdle View Post
Various letters of Paul to and from Seneca? I assume you want a list of everything including forgeries, and then we can sift those.
That's roughly the idea. There should in theory be a finite list
of these citations capable of being indexed in a chronological
order such as the draft above.

Quote:
Does ECW cover this?
The data is probably there but not specific to this "view"
which seeks to identify only the non-christian references
to christianity and/or the communications of christians to
the community of the Roman empire at large during the
pre-Nicene epoch.

Quote:
Edict of Milan is about religious tolerance - does it mention xianity?
This is just a brief chronological placemark for the appearance
of Constantine into the picture, no more at present.
mountainman is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:14 AM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.