Doctor X

Does one have to get "honorarily" circumcised?

--J.D.

punta

...Welcome to the forums!

thankyou. i've actually been here before. i just don't get out much .

punta

that would be point number five he is claiming to have demonstrated:

"...Fifthly it shows that the ideology that many calls Judaism is not a religion, but a political system, bent on enslaving the world including you...."



i thought this guy might have been trouble but he is clearly some moron cribbing his notes from some hate site.

he has been unable to respond to a single counter and refused to respond to me when i was there countering him (although i see he came circling back later to puff up his chest and blow some more smoke. guess i'll have to go back).

RED DAVE

Posted by Punta:Wrong. Racism is certainly present in Judaism: there are some racial slurs about Black people in the Talmud that will curl your hair. Please note, however, that Orthodox Jews, who subscribe to such nonsense, make up less that 5% of all Jews.

It is true that according to Orthodox law, only the child of a Jewish mother is considered Jewish. However, most modern Jews ignore such nonsense. And, by the way, conversion to judaism is posssible and is no more difficult than coversion to xtianity. (The difference is that judaism doesn't prosylethize.) This final sentence is an out and out racial slander. If you want to go by the law, fathering illegitimate children is a sin.

This is just antisemitic rambling. The Talmud represents interpretations and updating of the laws in the Bible. The implication is that there is something sinister about the development of Jewish law over hundreds of years. As to xtianity, developing from judaism, sure. But I don't think I have to remind people on this board of how quickly and decisively it diverged. That stuff about Hebrew is just paranoia.

Just crazy. Latin died in the humanities 400 or so years and more ago as each European country developed its own intelligentisia and artists outside the church. The stuff about terminology is nuts.

Ranting. Just ranting.

Large sections of the Talmud are already available, in English, online.
Jewish Sacred Texts

As to Jews ruling the world and America, standard ranting. Israel, as the US stalking horse in the Mid-East gets aid. But it is a miniscule amount of dough compared with the expenditures of the US government, overall. (It averages to about $2 billion a year over the past 50 years or about $100 billion. Consider that Bush is asking for $87 billion for a supplement for Iraq for this year!)

Punta, this is actually very low-level antisemitism. It's really just an extended, hysterical screech. There's practically no content to it. (Where are the sinister power of the Rothchild Bank, Jewish Bolsheviks, the Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion?) This guy ought to go to Aryan Nations school or something like that and learned his antisemitism. This is daycare stuff.

RED DAVE

punta

thanks for all your help.

very kindy-garten hate-mongering i now realize. all-in-all he came across looking very silly (i think).

he's more Farrakhan than Aryan Nations.

Doctor X

Red Dave:

Now that is an insult! Reminds me of the, actually, underated film Porky's--Director's Cut available on Beta!--where a Jew responds to a bigot who calls him a "kite"--"I guess you're too stupid to be a good bigot!"

[Ascends Soapbox] It can prove both painful and time consuming to fight such cretins of hate; yet those who do deserve support. Rarely will one change a racist, but one may prevent someone from becoming a racist.

--J.D.