Freethought & Rationalism ArchiveThe archives are read only. |
04-09-2001, 04:56 PM | #1 |
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Galilee and Nazareth
I received the following email.
Offa: What are your sources/references for the following quote from one of your posts in infidels.org: "You are right that Jesus of Nazareth never existed, that is, if you are referring to the Nazareth adjoining to the sea of Galilee. The location of Galilee in the gospels is a pseudo location." My answer to that question is, first and foremost, I write my own stuff. I have numerous sources taken from The Works of Josephus. I am wary of cutting and pasting my sources because of a statement in the book that says, "No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without prior permission from the publisher." The problem with Josephus is that you need to read several paragraphs in order to understand exactly what he is talking about. I bought a hardcover of "Works" using www.amazon.com. In Antiquities, chapter 11-2 Josephus tells about the other Strato's Tower. He tells us, just one time in the voluminous Works that the Essenes used pseudo-names for locations. What he does not tell you is that he already had been using pseudo-names throughout his Antiquities. It becomes quite obvious that he does that with Tyre because he mentions other locations for Tyre. Using logic you will realize that any ruler of Tyre will be called "Hiram". In Antiquities, chapter 1-3 Josephus tells about the Geon river running through Egypt and that the Greeks call this river the Nile. What Josephus is doing is talking about "two Egypts". Josephus' contemporaries with knowledge of the Essene writing style know that he is talking about two Egypts but those without this knowledge will be duped into thinking that the Nile and the Geon are the same river. The beginning of 14-9 tells about Antipator giving his son Herod (future king Herod the Great) the governorship of Galilee. Those without knowledge are duped into believing that this Galilee is the location of the Lake Galilee well north of Judea. It is not. This Galilee is the area along the northwest corner of the Dead Sea. Herod purges Galilee of a band of robbers and is beloved by the Syrians which tells you that Syria is also local to Jerusalem as is this Galilee (Qumran). In 14-15 Josephus tells the wary reader about the caves and the abrupt precipices located in Galilee. These are the caves cut in the cliffs alongside the Dead Sea. It even becomes obvious that his Jordan river is actually the wady Kidron. thanks, offa |
04-09-2001, 05:34 PM | #2 |
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Staggering, offa -- just staggering.
PS: a word of warning, cuting and pasting is still reproduction of that work -- it falls under the "in part" part. |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|