FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Archives > Religion (Closed) > Biblical Criticism & History
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Today at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 11-10-2010, 04:32 PM   #1
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: seattle, wa
Posts: 9,337
Default The Marcionite Interest in a Hermaphrodite God

I have always noticed that Gregory Nazianzen has a lot of interesting and new information about the Marcionites that is generally unrecognized. Here is another:

But if you would be silly enough to say, with the old myths and fables, that God begat the Son by a marriage with His own Will, we should be introduced to the Hermaphrodite god of Marcion and Valentinus who imagined these newfangled Æons [The Fifth Theological Oration 7]
stephan huller is offline  
Old 11-10-2010, 07:11 PM   #2
Contributor
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Falls Creek, Oz.
Posts: 11,192
Default

Isn't this extract from Gregory Nazianzen (329-390 CE) seen as characteristic of his invectives against Arianism? Do you happen to know how many times Gregory Nazianzen mentions "Marcion" (085-160 CE) and/or "Marcionites" in his extant works? Frequently or rarely?
mountainman is offline  
Old 11-10-2010, 08:29 PM   #3
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: seattle, wa
Posts: 9,337
Default

More than you'd think. I would say a dozen times. I might be wrong but that's what memory tells me
stephan huller is offline  
Old 11-13-2010, 06:39 PM   #4
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Texas
Posts: 5,810
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by stephan huller View Post
More than you'd think. I would say a dozen times. I might be wrong but that's what memory tells me
I think you should do more thinking about Marcion. Marcion was declared a heretic for his thinking about the Trinity. He did not say that God, Jesus and the Holy Spirt were one, but attacked God and said Jesus was second to God. I do not know where you God your facts. More heresy came with Arius and his followers.
aeebee50 is offline  
Old 11-13-2010, 07:01 PM   #5
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: seattle, wa
Posts: 9,337
Default

Really? I have spent twenty five years thinking about Marcion. I think that's sufficient to earn the right to have an observation or two.

Quote:
Marcion was declared a heretic for his thinking about the Trinity. He did not say that God, Jesus and the Holy Spirt were one, but attacked God and said Jesus was second to God. I do not know where you God your facts. More heresy came with Arius and his followers.
I don't know where you get your facts from but if your argument is that Marcionitism is related to early Arianism we're basically in agreement. Of course I would argue that this represents the true Christian religion. I have a suspicion you might disagree with that.
stephan huller is offline  
Old 11-13-2010, 10:20 PM   #6
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Texas
Posts: 5,810
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by stephan huller View Post
Really? I have spent twenty five years thinking about Marcion. I think that's sufficient to earn the right to have an observation or two.

Quote:
Marcion was declared a heretic for his thinking about the Trinity. He did not say that God, Jesus and the Holy Spirt were one, but attacked God and said Jesus was second to God. I do not know where you God your facts. More heresy came with Arius and his followers.
I don't know where you get your facts from but if your argument is that Marcionitism is related to early Arianism we're basically in agreement. Of course I would argue that this represents the true Christian religion. I have a suspicion you might disagree with that.
I do, but that what makes it great, to be able to disgree.
aeebee50 is offline  
Old 11-16-2010, 10:15 AM   #7
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Dallas Texas
Posts: 758
Default

Stephen:

When you claim that Marcion represents the "true" Christian religion you men true in what sense?

Steve
Juststeve is offline  
Old 11-16-2010, 10:29 AM   #8
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: seattle, wa
Posts: 9,337
Default

Well at its simplest I guess 'true' means 'original.'

The Marcionites didn't accept Acts or the deutero-Pauline canon which is a point in their favor. They couldn't have believed in the idea of a 'primitive Church' (no Acts). They had a completely different paradigm centered around (a) the revelation of something better than Moses to 'the apostle,' (b) this 'unspeakable' revelation leading to the composition of the original gospel narrative and (c) this gospel superficially resembling the general form of our existing narratives save for the fact that (i) Jesus is wholly divine (ii) that he came to announce someone else - presumably the apostle who wrote the gospel - as the messiah and (iii) that this announcement was tied to a Jubilee (hence the name 'gospel').

In short I think the Marcionite tradition makes more sense, is likely quite a rational argument, and is more closely aligned to traditional Jewish messianism.
stephan huller is offline  
Old 11-16-2010, 10:55 AM   #9
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: On the path of knowledge
Posts: 8,889
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by stephan huller View Post
if your argument is that Marcionitism is related to early Arianism we're basically in agreement. Of course I would argue that this represents the true Christian religion.
Wow, something that we agree on finally. Guess this is proof that miracles do happen!
Sheshbazzar is offline  
Old 11-16-2010, 11:37 AM   #10
Banned
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Alberta
Posts: 11,885
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by stephan huller View Post
Really? I have spent twenty five years thinking about Marcion. I think that's sufficient to earn the right to have an observation or two.
. . . and I know of this Shakespeare critic who spend 40 years studying him and upon retirement concluded that she really did not understand him.
Quote:

Quote:
Marcion was declared a heretic for his thinking about the Trinity. He did not say that God, Jesus and the Holy Spirt were one, but attacked God and said Jesus was second to God. I do not know where you God your facts. More heresy came with Arius and his followers.
I don't know where you get your facts from but if your argument is that Marcionitism is related to early Arianism we're basically in agreement. Of course I would argue that this represents the true Christian religion. I have a suspicion you might disagree with that.
Yes it could very well represent the true Christian religon which still is an abomination today in that Christian-ity as the condition of being wherein we have the mind of Christ and so are Christian is the end of religion.
Chili is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:52 PM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.