Albert09

Que de la verdadera inexistencia de Dios se sigue su existencia.

1) Toda verdad remite a otra. De lo contrario, el l�*mite de la verdad ser�*a una no-verdad, en la que aquélla encontrar�*a su comienzo y su fin. Lo falso engendrar�*a a lo cierto, y lo cierto a lo falso.

2) Las verdades, pues, sean cuales sean, nos conducen, mediante un encadenamiento infinito, a la Verdad suprema e inalcanzable, que es Dios.

3) Afirmar una sola verdad que sea tal, y no sólo de nombre, supone negar el l�*mite que la cancelar�*a, afirmar la infinitud de la progresión y, por consiguiente, afirmar a Dios.

4) Luego, aunque esa supuesta verdad fuera "Dios no existe", al predicarse como verdad, de ella se sigue que Dios, es decir la Verdad, existe.

5) Pero, si Dios existe, la mayor es falsa, y si no existe también, pues no existe la Verdad ni tampoco las verdades. Luego, de un modo u otro, Dios existe.

Jesse

As with the previous thread you started, this does not belong in S&S.

Cynical-Chick

No, no hay un Dios. Lo siento mucho.


"serêa"
Que? El "ê" no existe en español.

MrFrosty

The quality of this thread floweth over

Weltall

How... useful. I'm guessing that the general thrust of the argument is 'God exists because I say so'. Anyone who speaks Spanish able to tell me if I'm close?

AndresDeLaHoz

That probably is a badly formatted é.

The argument seems to be this:

- The truth leads to the ultimate Truth, which is God.
- God does not exist is true.
- Therefore, God exists and is the Truth.

Azathoth

Brilliant! By posting in a language that many here don't speak,he's avoided the thorny problem of having everyone refute it.

For his next post,I'd suggest going with Klingon. There are probably less speakers of that than the Spanish speakers,so virtually no one will be able to respond.

He'll be able to say,truthfully,that no one could answer his arguments.

If he can sufficiently couch it in gibberish,as well as some of the other posters that end up Elsewhere,he may have an unbeatable combination.

Mr. Neutron

Judging by how many Trek geeks there are on this board, I'm not too sure about that.

Weltall

Nahh, remember that all people who love Sci Fi are Evil Atheists (TM), so of course everyone here should be able to speak it. May I complement you on that line though, you owe me a new keyboard.

orpheus last chant

Heh, I'm a latin-based language speaker. I could understand, even if I don't know french. Not only is his argument strangely in a languange that most of the posters don't know....it's not even original! IIRC, millenia old really.

It's a strange version of uncaused cause, only it's with truths this time. Apparently if you go back by truths, you must reach the original truth - God.

Would you like fries with that non-sequitur?