FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Elsewhere > ~Elsewhere~
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Yesterday at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 10-24-2003, 12:36 AM   #61
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: North of the South Pole
Posts: 5,177
Default

I know I'm going to regret getting into this, but...

Quote:
Originally posted by hope's daughter
Oh give me a break...what atheist is not proud of being an atheist. Yes read the sentence again. They want to be different and get a kick out of saying, "I am different, try to convert me, nananana Boo Boo." It is just another form of rebellion. Kid's stuff really.
Why do you pretend to know what goes on in other people's minds?

Also, you really need to understand that we don't believe your mythology. It has nothing to do with rebellion and everything to do with critical thinking. Quite simple, really.

Quote:
Sell me short but don�t sell GOD short. He is mighty and powerful, full of compassion and loving kindness towards you. Don�t turn from HIM for HE is the source of intellect, more specifically wisdom which is the ability to put knowledge to use.. Don�t doubt HE exists because you can�t see HIM. You can�t see me yet I exist.
Your existence can be proven. Can you(or anyone else) prove your god's existence? If yes, please show us. If not, why should we believe it is any different from a belief in Santa Claus, or, for that matter, Hank?

Quote:
You see the words I type. God has words too that He wishes you to examine critically It is called the Holy Bible
I'm sure this has already been explained to you in your time on these boards, but many people here have studied the holey buy-bull critically and in depth, and found it severely lacking in credibility.
mongrel is offline  
Old 10-24-2003, 12:58 AM   #62
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: UK
Posts: 168
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by hope's daughter
[B][/I]Why because I am a woman and I do not want to be treated like a man? Why would this offend you? I think I should be the one offended since it seems you wish to label me a non-generic sex. Maybe to then throw all manners out the window. Just conjecture on my part.
Why must manners be based on sexual inequality? I generally hold the door for whoever's walking behind me be they man or woman because I think it's just damn rude not to.

I think what King Rat found offensive was your arrogence in refering to women as "the weaker sex" without first checking if that was OK with the 3 Billion or so other women on this planet.
eifion is offline  
Old 10-24-2003, 05:21 AM   #63
relight
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

well i went and checked the user cp.... this thread has turned really spicy...

hope's daughter: You have the right to believe whatever you want, I think we can't disprove god's existence either.... BUT the christian god is a very flawed design however.so I think dissecting and understanding your god can give you positive insights, and allow you to "recreate" your own personal god into a more complete, undefeatable version.

Just remember that the bible is full of lies and myths... so i think there is a need for hardcore christians to understand and reshape their own god.
 
Old 10-24-2003, 05:45 AM   #64
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Ill
Posts: 6,577
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by hope's daughter
Oh give me a break...what atheist is not proud of being an atheist. Yes read the sentence again. They want to be different and get a kick out of saying, "I am different, try to convert me, nananana Boo Boo." It is just another form of rebellion. Kid's stuff really. Okay I know I will get in trouble....
Yes, I think you will get in trouble for saying atheism is "kid's stuff". It's not exactly respectful. But at least you knew you were being provocative...

Helen
HelenM is offline  
Old 10-24-2003, 08:04 AM   #65
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 6,855
Default

>>Snipped the irrelevant and impotent responses<<

Quote:
Depends on what data and what position you speak of.
Oh, some authentic archeological data would be nice. IOW, NOT the shroud of Turin, NOT the fake ossuary, NOT fake pieces of the cross, NOT the holy grail, NOT the hundreds of other hoaxes xians seem to love perpetrating on each other.

Quote:
I don't know why you would want me too, since you are so adamant about your basic tenets of your faith. What is the use in trying? You give me nothing to work with. You already have your mind made up that is if you believe in something as elusive and obscure as a �mind�
I have no faith, how many times must I say it to you? I've given you a challenge, a challenge that an omnipotent god should find unremarkable and simple.

Quote:
You are so silly. *I* can not save anyone.
That, HD, is self evident. Forgive me for stating the obvious.

Quote:
Now YOU will have to be specific 'cause I do not know what the heck you speak of King of the Rats. Are you related to �Rat Boy�?
Wow, you really can't remember what you wrote...

Hope's Daughter wrote:

Quote:
There could be a fifth option: God exits and has given you these gifts so that one day you will use them to His glory. This seems to be more sensible than 1-4. Just my 2 cents.
That is the nonsensical fifth option that your proposed. HD, you cannot post something like that and claim it sensible without some sort of data to back it up. Without data it is an empty, frivolous, Hallmark card assertion. I find it eminently frustrating that you are incapable of keeping track of what you say.

Quote:
What do you believe? That it is the gift to ourselves? This makes no sense. We are so darn selfish. BTW I am not the starter of this thread but it is a beautiful one indeed. For God has been the inspiration of music for centuries. HE gives us many ways to express ourselves.
Music is my gift to you. You can try to spin that as selfish if you desire. You are not the OP, but you tried to fortify the OP's foundation of sand.

Quote:
And YOU cannot prove that it isn't, but without God, the kind of love mankind experiences is empty, unsatisfactory and fruitless. I will stand by these words.
On the contrary, I find my life of love to be full, satisfying, and it bears a multitude of fruits. I could care less if love is a chemical process, it does not diminish it's profound effects upon my life. Why must everything be mystical and inexplicable in order to have value for xians?

Quote:
I don't know how you can state this unless you think you are better than me. Okay you are smarter. Does that stroke your ego? Hope you are satisfied.
The only thing that satisfies me is your belated recognition of at least one fact. One has to start somewhere, so I'll take what I can get.

Quote:
So? What is your beef? I like to tell people things like �God bless you� and �Have a great day�, �Take care�, �Drive Safetly� and stuff like that. What are you weird? Don�t you also give words of encouragement to people? King Rat I do not know what you are complaining about.......Why? It is the highest form of compliment a person can pay to another individual. Why must you look on it negatively? God honors mankind by making man in God�s image. King Rat let me ask you if I met you and then said to you, �King your face looks like a monkey.� verses �God�s light shines in your eyes.�, which would attract you? What if what I stated was the truth and I could see you reflect God�s character: purity, wisdom, meekness, love and decency, why then should I keep it to myself? Why not let you know?
I give words of encouragemet and compliments all the time. They are more along the lines of:

"All your hard work paid off."
"You are a freakin' machine."
"You are the most beautiful thing I've ever seen."
etc.

I hate diminishing anyones efforts by ascribing said efforts to an imaginary deity. To do so, gives credit where it is not due.

Quote:
If I truly believed I needed to extend to you an apology I would not hesitate to give it so do not hesitate to let me in on any insults you find on my part. Whether you will extend the same consideration to me is of no mind. My character is such that when I have truly wronged an individual I always wish to make amends. Call it my Achilles heel.
I apologize freely to those I have wronged.

Quote:
Why because I am a woman and I do not want to be treated like a man? Why would this offend you? I think I should be the one offended since it seems you wish to label me a non-generic sex. Maybe to then throw all manners out the window. Just conjecture on my part.
I won't even touch this one. It is not up to me to explain your place in the world, your qualifications, your rights, etc. I do however find your comments to be profoundly sad.

Quote:
Oh give me a break...what atheist is not proud of being an atheist. Yes read the sentence again. They want to be different and get a kick out of saying, "I am different, try to convert me, nananana Boo Boo." It is just another form of rebellion. Kid's stuff really. Okay I know I will get in trouble....
Kids stuff eh? HD, you are truly a shining representative of your religion. Your adherence to your god's tenets is remarkably consistent, I'll give you that.

Quote:
Oh really? King Rat let me in on your secret. How you can do this thing: recall exactly what you say, exactly why you say it (must know yourself pretty well) AND when you say it. (must have a photographic memory. Sounds like you have super human capabilities. I am impressed. I can barely remember my name.
Not superhuman, just plain old human. And yes, I do know myself pretty well, I highly recommend self examination HD. You'd be suprised at the untapped well that is your mind. Over time you may even be able to keep track of your name.

Quote:
Sell me short but don�t sell GOD short. He is mighty and powerful, full of compassion and loving kindness towards you. Don�t turn from HIM for HE is the source of intellect, more specifically wisdom which is the ability to put knowledge to use.. Don�t doubt HE exists because you can�t see HIM. You can�t see me yet I exist. You see the words I type. God has words too that He wishes you to examine critically It is called the Holy Bible
Witness schmitness... My critical examination of the babble is why I am an atheist. Physician, heal thyself...

Quote:
Well then why did you write it and while you are at it who are you?
HD, I've enjoyed our lightweight little spar, but I also know an exercise in futility when I see one. Besides I have never talked to anyone so willing to denigrate themselves. Why should I examine you when you won't even examine yourself?
King Rat is offline  
Old 10-24-2003, 09:13 AM   #66
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: middle earth
Posts: 601
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by mongrel
I know I'm going to regret getting into this, but...
Please wade in mongrel...the water is fine...

Quote:
Why do you pretend to know what goes on in other people's minds?
I only know people's minds if they make themselves known by their words. A person' words carry a lot of weight as to who that person is and what is on their mind. I prefer those who speak their minds to those who hide behind empty words and are afraid to venture into areas that might leave one uncomfortable. It is call risked taking. I have found certain Atheists and Christians alike more honest than others in this regard. I know alot of silliness goes on on theses boards, (can't take things too seriously or life will loose it's joy), but there is a place to tackle serious subjects in a respectful way to both parties.

Quote:
Also, you really need to understand that we don't believe your mythology. It has nothing to do with rebellion and everything to do with critical thinking. Quite simple, really.
It is not a myth. Christ lived and He died. It is up to you as whether you are brave enough to look at His claims. Re-examine them again if you have already. Carefully evaluate the Scriptures. Pray...do you pray while you critically test and formulate your opinion or have you spent too many years in institutions which promote a politically correct view of the world? Are you the type that just dimisses things because it does not line up with what your version of reality is? If this is the case you have not examined the gospel critically. If you did I think you would be amazed about what you find.

Quote:
Your existence can be proven. Can you(or anyone else) prove your god's existence? If yes, please show us. If not, why should we believe it is any different from a belief in Santa Claus, or, for that matter, Hank?
I have been acquanted with this link. I think you would have a hard time proving I (the person) exist. I could be a bunch of monkey's typing. Christ though is mentioned in Non-Christian writings.

Quote:
I'm sure this has already been explained to you in your time on these boards, but many people here have studied the holey buy-bull critically and in depth, and found it severely lacking in credibility.
What I normally find is that, even though there are a few who have acquired a high degree of knowledge of Scripture, most atheist's that I run into dismiss Scripture without examining the truth or its veracity.
hope's daughter is offline  
Old 10-24-2003, 09:26 AM   #67
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: middle earth
Posts: 601
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by eifion
Why must manners be based on sexual inequality? I generally hold the door for whoever's walking behind me be they man or woman because I think it's just damn rude not to.

I think what King Rat found offensive was your arrogence in refering to women as "the weaker sex" without first checking if that was OK with the 3 Billion or so other women on this planet.
I am sorry eirion that my point evaded you but then that is my point. I do not want to be treated like a man. I want someone to be respectful towards me because I am a woman. Call me old fashion but I believe in opening a door for a woman because she is a woman. These days some woman will look at you (If you are a man) like you have just commited murder if you open the door for them. I also believe in the work place men should be respectful and watch their language around women.

Well if King Rat is a women I will not apologize and if this person is a male no apology either. Women are the weaker sex literally. Heck what are women looking for in a male, amonst other things, but security and protection.
hope's daughter is offline  
Old 10-24-2003, 09:36 AM   #68
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: middle earth
Posts: 601
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by relight
well i went and checked the user cp.... this thread has turned really spicy...
What do you expect? We have a bunch of cooks on this thread

Quote:
hope's daughter: You have the right to believe whatever you want, I think we can't disprove god's existence either.... BUT the christian god is a very flawed design however.so I think dissecting and understanding your god can give you positive insights, and allow you to "recreate" your own personal god into a more complete, undefeatable version.
Relight I am not going to get into a discussion of your failings. Why? You probably have many. You are human. But by nature and definition God is perfect. He defines what you are not. Sorry. I know it is a little disappointing but then again that is why God would want you to turn to Him so He could help you with those imperfections.

Quote:
Just remember that the bible is full of lies and myths... so i think there is a need for hardcore christians to understand and reshape their own god.
Please the church is trying it your way to (I think) the detrement of the church...contemporary service along with a watered down gospel. It is so ineffectual and doctrinal truths are falling by the way side. But let me ask...who has been lying to you? Myth? Is King Solomon's temple a myth? Jerusalemn? Garden of Gethsemene? Nazereth? You can got to these places today.
hope's daughter is offline  
Old 10-24-2003, 09:39 AM   #69
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: middle earth
Posts: 601
Default

Quote:
Originally posted by HelenM
Yes, I think you will get in trouble for saying atheism is "kid's stuff". It's not exactly respectful. But at least you knew you were being provocative...

Helen
Helen,

All I can say is, "Mommy I promise I will be good."

p.s. Mr. or Mrs. rat I will be back....
hope's daughter is offline  
Old 10-24-2003, 10:25 AM   #70
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Ill
Posts: 6,577
Cool

Quote:
Originally posted by hope's daughter
Helen,

All I can say is, "Mommy I promise I will be good."
Well...don't make any promises you can't keep, ok?

Helen
HelenM is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:23 PM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.