Occam's Aftershave

Ooh! Ooh! It's the return of DopeyDave, Flood Geologist^(tm)

Dave, please show us the working of that open mind and explain:

1. How does a 200,000+ year old geologic formation support a 6000 year old Earth?
2. How do 5 million year old mountains support a 6000 year old Earth?
3. How did da FLUD produce mile deep incised meanders?
4. How did da FLUD produce vertical folded unconformaties?
5. Where in Egypt can we see this 1 mi. deep sedimentary layer?

and finally Dave, your favorite question that you've cowardly refused to address for 413 straight days now, including your CM debate:

Why do the multiple independent C14 cal curves all cross-correlate so closely, and all show dates well older than 10,000 years?

Ya know Dave, every last one of your incredibly stupid "open minded' FLUD claims have been thoroughly debunked IN GREAT DETAIL on other threads. You know it, we know it. Why do you insist on droning on about the same refuted horsecrap?

deadman_932

So, Dave, have you ever found ONE modern mammal fossil in the Morrison Formation?

Did you ever show how the Morrison dates are incorrect, given that I gave you oh, a couple of dozen radiometric dates on it from multiple methods?

Show me WHY I should accept that this magic flood deposited the Morrison so perfectly , and other strata like limestone SO neatly while in the middle of a year-long flood? Why didn't the walls of the Grand Canyon slump, Dave?

Why do you continue to avoid presenting evidence that would SUPPORT your claims and why do you instead always seek to twist science as you did with the English Channel article...an article that dates the release of Glacially-dammed flood waters at FAR beyond your flood date?

deadman_932

And once again, Brave Sir Davey flees the building.

deadman_932

OH, by the way Dave, besides the dating on the English Channel event, I'd like you to explain how it formed a "sub-horizontal bench (~4 KM wide ,~ 25 KM long) cut into CHALK BEDROCK" (my emphasis). That's on page 343 of the English Channel article:

Gupta, S. Jenny Collier, Andy Palmer-Felgate and Graeme Potter (2007) "Catastrophic Flooding Origin of Shelf Valley Systems in the English Channel." Nature 448:7151, pp. 342-345. 19 July.

How did that Chalk bedrock layer get there given even the most fantastic deposition rates in your "Young Earth Dreams/Miracles"??

Worldtraveller

ck1 asks Not as some kind of standard practice, but feel free to post one, it might be worth posting a thread over in E/C to notify some of the regulars there that might have been following the trouncing debate.

afdave says:
Finally, something we can all agree on.

I look forward to the results of the poll.

Cheers,
Lane

Pilsboy5

I've a feeling it'll be a close call

Faid

Boy, that was a pathetic last post. But then, it was expected.

I needn't comment on any of dave's already demolished (here, and elsewhere) claims: All I have to do is remind people that:

Although CM responded to all of dave's questions, dave obviously, deliberately, desperately denied to reply to at least one specific one of CM's, up to his last post.

And that question was "explain the consillience between entirely different dating methods".

Dave had no answer. Dave lost. No poll is needed.

Seeya, dave.

Faid

Oh and dave- what are you doing in this thread, restating the same old refuted claims, as if they were something new that was never addressed?

Why don't you return to those old threads you abandoned, where your "arguments" were demolished, and try to resurrect them there with some extra support, if you can?

Or are you glad they fell back, and got buried, and hope that people will forget about them, and all those questions you run away from?

This is not a different forum, dave. It's still IIDb; you can't use your favorite tactics now. I you have something to say about all those claims, do so in the threads you first made them, or the ones made for just that reason. And answer all the objections and questions waiting for you there.

Let's see if you can stand the heat for once.

mung bean

Dave? Stand the heat? Deal with questions?
:rolling: :rolling: :rolling: :rolling: :rolling: :rolling:
Nice one , Faid. You da funny man.

Nialler

I thought that this quote showed stunning lack of logic:

Stunning lack of logic there. If the founding date of Egypt were shown to be as he claims, all it would do is to remove an objection to the flood myth, but it would not add one jit or tottle of evidence for it.