FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Archives > Religion (Closed) > Biblical Criticism & History
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Yesterday at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 04-02-2009, 06:42 PM   #261
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: On the path of knowledge
Posts: 8,889
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by bacht View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sheshbazzar View Post
Far better then that men would cultivate and nourish a true and genuine love of the truth, in truth, for the sake of THE truth, rather than the noxious vines of these primitive so-called religions that poison and inflame men's minds with half-truths and outright lies...

As for my name Sheshbazzar, it has been with me many years, even long before I ever heard of the Internet. From the beginning it has represented a task that is not yet accomplished, and understandings that my fellow men have not yet attained to, but among whom, as befitting a prince and a prophet of the seed of Israel, I labor in complete certainty of confidence that the day will yet come, when all men everywhere shall understand perfectly. Then my name will be changed.
Well, I used to be an idealist. All I can say is good luck, I don't see the mass of humanity embracing Truth anytime soon.
Me neither, but I live today, am patient, and am very optimistic that in due time, that which is the best that is within mankind will overcome our faults.
They who are willing, cannot as yet embrace that which they cannot yet comprehend. When honest and just men do come to know the better, they then will embrace truth as though it were the child they so long yearned for.
As scripture says; "...in the latter days ye shall consider it perfectly."
Quote:
Originally Posted by bacht
Fear and ignorance are the real demons haunting humanity since the beginning afaics.
Yes, and it is a crying shame, the fear that is wasted upon silly superstitions, rather than a healthy and beneficial fear of not doing ones best. And a fear of increasing knowledge, and understanding, while fearfully choosing to remain in ignorance, and desiring all others to so remain.
Sheshbazzar is offline  
Old 04-04-2009, 05:42 AM   #262
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: illinois
Posts: 688
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by bacht View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by kcdad View Post

Mankind isn't evil. Mankind is an animal that wants to survive.

What you call evil is what another man calls survival. I use violence against you because you, or someone like you, first used violence against me...
I'm using the word "evil" as shorthand for all the ways we mistreat each other and ourselves.

Stress and anxiety can induce bad behaviour, but we're still autonomous actors, we're not passive robots.

We've inherited many physical and mental processes from our animal cousins, but we have far more self-awareness and freedom of action. Whether we like it or not we do have conscience and understanding of morality. Only the insane can be excused from this.

It's been fashionable for several generations to pretend that humans are just animals, but this is childish. We're more than animals, and we deny this at our peril.
OK... I'll try again...

We are animals. We are not spiritual creatures. We are made of the earth.
Yes, our cerebral cortex is more developed than other animals, but we can not do anything qualitatively different than other animals except... murder each other for pleasure.

I am curious as to how you see us being "more than" animals.
kcdad is offline  
Old 04-04-2009, 07:02 PM   #263
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: AUSTRALIA
Posts: 2,265
Thumbs up

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sheshbazzar View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by IamJoseph View Post

There is chosen - and there is chosen. Choose your chosen as you wish:

TO BE A LIGHT UNTO THE NATIONS

NO SALVATION BUT THROUGH ME

NO GOD WITHOUT MOHAMMED AS HIS PROPHET.


# Only one of the above allows you to have your own freely chosen belief. My math says millions of innocent folk were murdered because of bad chosen doctrines.
The problem is Joseph, that NONE of the above are as good as it could be, and all are false.
The G-d that is described in the writings of The TaNaKa, is an insane boogeyman only suitable for the terrorising of little children, and superstitious
and unlearned goat herders, the fearful, and the weak-minded.
Without The TaNaKa, I may have believed, but after having read, and having given long thought to what is recorded in The TaNaKa about the ways and the acts of the G-d of the Hebrews, I am revolted and repelled by the type of G-d that the Hebrew scriptures reveal.
Small wonder that so many wanted to escape from that monstrous and evil cult being forced upon them by Moses and his gang of murderous extortionists.

I utterly reject your Jew G-d as a vile and evil fabrication of men.
I do not choose between these evil branches growing out of one and the same rotten stump; NONE of them were "chosen"; They all alike are liars, thieves, murders. The offspring of an evil religious cult that pollutes and warps men's minds with silly lies, baited with worthless promises.
But I trust, and I have all confidence, that this bigold tree that is rotten right down to the roots, will die, and all of its poisonous branches will die along with it. It will soon fall apart from all the rot that has so long infested it, like every other ancient and rotten tree, its days are numbered, it will fall, it will fall, and soon be forgotten.
Every day, I lay my axe to the rotten roots to hasten the day.

According to the Hebrew bible, you can choose any belief you like, and you get equal rights - only your deeds and actions matter. But I would be more impressed if you posted complete sentences of the Hebrew bible. Children are not killed, and this contradicts the sublime Hebrew laws. The examples you will quote are limited to ancient modes of warfare, some of which never allowed taking prisoners, and applies both ways if Israel lost; here the Hebrew bible is a book of historical truth - read elsewhere of history if you doubt this.

The Hebrew bible's majestic uthenticity is it does not candy coat as does other scriptures - all wrongs are mentined without pulling any punches. This is not a book based on belief but factual history. Its laws rule the world today - excusively. :wave:
IamJoseph is offline  
Old 04-04-2009, 07:07 PM   #264
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: AUSTRALIA
Posts: 2,265
Thumbs up

Quote:
Originally Posted by kcdad View Post

Can you explain a little more about "inexplicable compulsions"?
Can you explain how Europeans took on board a belief via 2nd and 3rd hand sources and never asked for proof - would you today?

Quote:

"we have no explanation how a great idea comes into a man's mind"

Yes, we do. Creativity is the association of diverse pieces of information put to new uses.

They don't appear from nothing. You might want to look into James Burke's ideas of the Knowledge Web.

I am talking about 'association of diverse pieces of information put to new uses' and 'ideas of the Knowledge'!
IamJoseph is offline  
Old 04-04-2009, 07:10 PM   #265
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: AUSTRALIA
Posts: 2,265
Thumbs up

Quote:
Originally Posted by spamandham View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by IamJoseph View Post

Enlighten me: how/why is it meaningless that if we backtrack to origins ultimately we must end up with one indivisable and irreducable entity?
A. Monotheism has nothing to do with mathematics.

Math has no meaning w/o it. And when I put my math hat on, I agree with genesis, everything in the universe had to have began as a duality.

This is true even if one proves it does not take two to tango.
IamJoseph is offline  
Old 04-04-2009, 07:33 PM   #266
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Middle of an orange grove
Posts: 671
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by IamJoseph View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by kcdad View Post

Can you explain a little more about "inexplicable compulsions"?
Can you explain how Europeans took on board a belief via 2nd and 3rd hand sources and never asked for proof - would you today?
Yes, I can...

Here is what made them convert to Christianity:

Wooster is offline  
Old 04-05-2009, 08:17 PM   #267
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: On the path of knowledge
Posts: 8,889
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by IamJoseph
This is not a book based on belief but factual history. Its laws rule the world today - excusively.
This is a book that is based on a fairy-tale about a talking snake, it is sadly lacking in historical accuracy, and what is there is warped to support the silly talking snake fable.
The Hebrew bible's laws DO NOT rule the world today, much less exclusively.
Sheshbazzar is offline  
Old 04-06-2009, 02:03 AM   #268
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: AUSTRALIA
Posts: 2,265
Thumbs up

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wooster View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by IamJoseph View Post

Can you explain how Europeans took on board a belief via 2nd and 3rd hand sources and never asked for proof - would you today?
Yes, I can...

Here is what made them convert to Christianity:

Christianity continued what Rome did - divine human emperors and heresy decrees. That the Gospels is a total lie may not be liked by my christians bretheren - but is not truth what sets one free - or is it 'belief' - even where truth is totally absent?

While none know for sure, it seems that one day a relic may be discovered which will prove the Gospels a fake - because truth is undestructable and always seems to bop up in the end. It is possible this can be the case also for Judaism - while the evidence does not agree with that as it does with the NT & Quran, nor is Judaism based on enforced conversion and missionising with free gifts.

Two theologies which go belly up in one stroke if the Gospels is found false, because the Quran condones core doctrines of the Gospels. Such a scenario poses a greater upheavel than a nuke war. One thing's for sure - christianity and islam will owe the Jews a life time of apologies if their scriptures prove false!
IamJoseph is offline  
Old 04-06-2009, 02:37 AM   #269
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: AUSTRALIA
Posts: 2,265
Thumbs up

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sheshbazzar View Post
[

I composed a long and detailed reply to this with many scriptural citations, unfortunately it disappeared when I attempted posting.
This one will be much shorter.

I empathise.

Quote:

The entire Hebrew bible is built around the premise of a talking snake that could carry on a conversation and reason with a human.
Very observant of you. It means the world turns on the Hebrew laws exclusively, and those are all snake laws. I wonder if the ToE'ists can come up with just one single law - and succeed in its enshrining in the world's judiciary systems - you think!? :huh:

Quote:
Every thing else contained within the bible is only so much window dressing ancillary to this silly tale, suffering, death, wars, deliverance's, and all other biblical stories are geared to the support of this looney tunes tale.
The Hebrew bible is NOT an accurate or actual history of anything.
Did you know, the mythical story of Joseph, who became vizir of ancient Egypt, is recorded in stone on one of the pyramids - and that it is contempoary in its dating - aligning with a mythical document called Genesis. Window dressing? - any other examples which equate with Genesis with equal veracity? - choose from anywhere in geo-history you like!?

Quote:
It is NOT a "historical truth" that the female of the human species was fashioned out of a rib-bone that was removed from a man.
The term 'rib' is a contrived translation of a mysterious Hebrew word which is not determinable; same with the fruit of the tree - its not an apple. In fact, even the serpent is not a serpent. I think even our state of art knowledge has not yet reached a point to understand this - but this will happen in the future. The relevency of the rib story is that a life is based on a dual-gendered entity when it first emerged. That is what modern science found when it discovered chromosomes some 3000 years later. Not bad, huh!


Quote:
It is NOT a "historical truth" that a serpent could carry on a conversation with a human.
And I vote that the most brilliant observation of all posts in this forum. Congrats.

Quote:
It is NOT a "historical truth" that Methuselah lived nine hundred and sixty nine years.
We have no records from that time - and there is absolutely no motive for Genesis to say so. Genesis is the only document which describes that history. But in the much later iron age, they would have not believed you if you said some people lived more than a 100 years today - because the ave span was 43 years for men; 31 for women in that time.

Quote:

It is NOT a "historical truth" that close to three million Hebrews wandered around the Sinai desert for forty years.
Did you do a scientific study to account for growth rates for a nation in a 400 year period? :constern01: Do you know where the first scientific cencus is from - with age, tribal and gender sub-totals and verifying sum totals - were is this recorded - which book?! And how come this nation survived a host of other war-like nations on their way to Canaan - because we know for a fact the Hebrews landed in Canaan and lived there till 586 BCE, then again till 70 CE. Well?

Quote:

It is NOT a "historical truth" that Balaam's ass was able to carry on a conversation and reason with him.
I would say its not a provable factor. However, Genesis presents this as a miracle and a metaphor between God and an Arabian prophet - who's curse was supposed to destroy a nation. Its all a matter of context, you know - and you omitted that part?

Quote:
On and on, .
There's no'on and on'. The Hebrew bible contains more scientifically verified historical truths - than any document in existence - for the longest period of time, and for the largest amount of stats - by a margin which leaves no equavalence. All you did was select the same 5 or 6 items which everyone likes to select - ignoring millions of other provable stats, and then quote them with no understanding of the text whatsoever, and by quoting half sentences. You even forgot to include the texts says the snake talked - BUT! - IN A REALM OUTSIDE OF THIS UNIVERSE! :wave:
IamJoseph is offline  
Old 04-06-2009, 03:50 AM   #270
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: On the path of knowledge
Posts: 8,889
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by IamJoseph View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sheshbazzar View Post

The problem is Joseph, that NONE of the above are as good as it could be, and all are false.
The G-d that is described in the writings of The TaNaKa, is an insane boogeyman only suitable for the terrorising of little children, and superstitious
and unlearned goat herders, the fearful, and the weak-minded.
Without The TaNaKa, I may have believed, but after having read, and having given long thought to what is recorded in The TaNaKa about the ways and the acts of the G-d of the Hebrews, I am revolted and repelled by the type of G-d that the Hebrew scriptures reveal.
Small wonder that so many wanted to escape from that monstrous and evil cult being forced upon them by Moses and his gang of murderous extortionists.

I utterly reject your Jew G-d as a vile and evil fabrication of men.
I do not choose between these evil branches growing out of one and the same rotten stump; NONE of them were "chosen"; They all alike are liars, thieves, murders. The offspring of an evil religious cult that pollutes and warps men's minds with silly lies, baited with worthless promises.
But I trust, and I have all confidence, that this bigold tree that is rotten right down to the roots, will die, and all of its poisonous branches will die along with it. It will soon fall apart from all the rot that has so long infested it, like every other ancient and rotten tree, its days are numbered, it will fall, it will fall, and soon be forgotten.
Every day, I lay my axe to the rotten roots to hasten the day.

According to the Hebrew bible, you can choose any belief you like, and you get equal rights - only your deeds and actions matter. But I would be more impressed if you posted complete sentences of the Hebrew bible. Children are not killed, and this contradicts the sublime Hebrew laws. The examples you will quote are limited to ancient modes of warfare, some of which never allowed taking prisoners, and applies both ways if Israel lost; here the Hebrew bible is a book of historical truth - read elsewhere of history if you doubt this.

The Hebrew bible's majestic uthenticity is it does not candy coat as does other scriptures - all wrongs are mentined without pulling any punches. This is not a book based on belief but factual history. Its laws rule the world today - excusively. :wave:
I composed a long and detailed reply to this with many scriptural citations, unfortunately it disappeared when I attempted posting.
This one will be much shorter.
The entire Hebrew bible is built around the premise of a talking snake that could carry on a conversation and reason with a human.
Every thing else contained within the bible is only so much window dressing ancillary to this silly tale, suffering, death, wars, deliverance's, and all other biblical stories are geared to the support of this looney tunes tale.
The Hebrew bible is NOT an accurate or actual history of anything.

It is NOT a "historical truth" that the female of the human species was fashioned out of a rib-bone that was removed from a man.

It is NOT a "historical truth" that a serpent could carry on a conversation with a human.

It is NOT a "historical truth" that Methuselah lived nine hundred and sixty nine years.

It is NOT a "historical truth" that close to three million Hebrews wandered around the Sinai desert for forty years.

It is NOT a "historical truth" that Balaam's ass was able to carry on a conversation and reason with him.

On and on, the Bible's UN-authenticity with its talking snakes, talking animals, and talking trees crap is NOT true.
Stories and claims that are unworthy of beliefe by any sane or rational person. Even the Brothers Grimm did a better job.
Sheshbazzar is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:05 PM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.