FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Archives > Existence of God(s)
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Yesterday at 03:12 PM

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 08-05-2006, 09:02 PM   #11
DBT
Contributor
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: ɹǝpunuʍop puɐן ǝɥʇ
Posts: 17,906
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
Maybe you guys can help me understand. Many of you seem so incredibly convinced there is no God. Yet, how can one be so convinced that this world wasn’t created/directed when the truth is that:

1) The origin of the Universe is still a mystery
Yes it is, but the question is - why do you have a need to fill the gaps in our understanding with myths?
Be honest with yourself and just live with the mystery.

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
2) The origin of the stars and galaxies is still a mystery
Not entirely, we know the processes underlying stellar and galactic formation. The basic principles of physics, gravity, orbital dynamics...

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
3) The origin of the solar system is still a mystery
As above.

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
4) The origin of the Earth, sun and moon is still a mystery
As above.
DBT is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:06 PM   #12
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: .
Posts: 187
Default

supersport, have you ever been to Auschwitz? Have you ever looked at the heaps of shoes and the heaps of hair? I have.

Sometimes I wish that god were real, so that I could spit in his face.

Before you give me any BS about free will, let me ask you this: suppose you had a 4 year old son who was boiling puppies alive. Would you stop him, or would you let him exercise his "free will"?

And to completely sidestep the free will issue, what about the 2004 tsunami? 200,000 people dead.

You can keep on worshipping a monster, I'm certainly not going to.
curbyIII is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:14 PM   #13
Banned
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: texas
Posts: 652
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by curbyIII
supersport, have you ever been to Auschwitz? Have you ever looked at the heaps of shoes and the heaps of hair? I have.

Sometimes I wish that god were real, so that I could spit in his face.

Before you give me any BS about free will, let me ask you this: suppose you had a 4 year old son who was boiling puppies alive. Would you stop him, or would you let him exercise his "free will"?

And to completely sidestep the free will issue, what about the 2004 tsunami? 200,000 people dead.

You can keep on worshipping a monster, I'm certainly not going to.
goodness. Why are you blaming this on God who gave people free will to do what they want?

God could not have a true, loving relationship with humans if He did not give them free will.

Your anger is misdirected. S
supersport is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:14 PM   #14
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: $1 reject store, St. Louis, MO
Posts: 94
Default

Using your own logic:

Things that are mysterious are things that are intelligently designed.
God is mysterious.
Therefore God is intelligently designed.
DrugFreeAlcoholic is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:17 PM   #15
DBT
Contributor
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: ɹǝpunuʍop puɐן ǝɥʇ
Posts: 17,906
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
goodness. Why are you blaming this on God who gave people free will to do what they want?

God could not have a true, loving relationship with humans if He did not give them free will.

Your anger is misdirected. S
Oh please, not the "free will" BS again. :banghead:
DBT is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:18 PM   #16
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Santa Rosa, CA
Posts: 2,817
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
1) The origin of the Universe is still a mystery
Quote:
2) The origin of the stars and galaxies is still a mystery
3) The origin of the solar system is still a mystery
4) The origin of the Earth, sun and moon is still a mystery
Head to Badastronomy.com for information on this. It's not as great a mystery as you seem to think.
Quote:
5) The origin of life from non-life is still a mystery
Partly. There are, however, a number of valid hypothesis floating around. Check with chemistry experts.
Quote:
6) The origin of consciousness is still a mystery
Not that much of one. It had to do with the development of the cerebral cortex, see...
Quote:
7) The origin of DNA is still a mystery
Once again: Not really. See my above post about hypothesis.
Quote:
8) The origin of the sexes is still a mystery
You really need to take a class in biology.
Quote:
9) The origin of language is still a mystery
A natural result in gradually increasing cognition.
Quote:
10) The origin of suddenly-appearing bones in the fossil records is still a mystery
You need to take a course in basic palentology, then.
Quote:
11) The origin of space and time and matter is still a mystery
Back to cosmology and astronomy.
Quote:
12) The origin of gravity and energy is a still a mystery
Natural properties of physical matter.
Quote:
13) The origin of Life is still a mystery
Take it to a chemist specialized in abiogenesis.
Quote:
14) The origin of Love is still a mystery
An emotional development that comes with higher cognative ability.
Quote:
15) The origin of sight is still a mystery
Another biology question.
Quote:
16) The origin of hearing, taste, touch and smell are still mysteries
And another.
Quote:
Why is it that food tastes so darn good?
If our taste buds did not identify tasty food, would you eat it?
Quote:
Why is it that music sounds so darn good?
The human ability to recognize and appriciate patterns.
Quote:
Why is it that sex feels so darn good?
Because if it didn't, our reproduction rate would be much less.
Quote:
Why is it that hugs and massages feel so darn good?
You do have nerves in your body, yes?
Quote:
Why is it that Creation looks so darn pretty?
Quote:
It seems to me that with all these things still mysteries, it would be hard for the average person to put so much faith in Godlessness.
Well, what can I say? There isn't any faith involved, "Godlessness" is a logical conclusion when examining the evidence. Besides...I'm not average.
Quote:
How could this world not be directed? It seems so obvious to me that we all are part of the Book of Life that God Created. Everything is so compicated on the inside (DNA, physics, chemistry, etc) yet so simple on the outside. We are obviously cherrished creatures. We are walking miracles......and no matter how elegant neo-darwinism may be to you, it simply cannot explain miracles. Yet that's what you're living.
Your incredulity does not make any of your assertions so. It works like this: If a process survives, then it continues to exist. If a process fails, it eventally ceases to exist. "Creation" is made up of the survivors.
Quote:
I used to accept evolution as a fact. But that has changed for me now due to the fact that I once said a simple, heart-felt prayer where I asked God to forgive me for a life of ignoring Him. My life has changed. I see everything differently now. I see the truth. I feel His love. I submit that I'm not a singular phenomenon. S
In other words, scientific study got too hard for you, so you threw it out in favor of the easy answers of superstition. Fine for you, I guess. Just don't try to push your superstitions into science classes or laboratories, and don't try to rewrite history.
Avatar is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:21 PM   #17
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Portland-upon-Willamette
Posts: 1,840
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
God could not have a true, loving relationship with humans if He did not give them free will.
So, God creates suffering and evil so that people can have the ability to love him? That's real selfless.
Veovis is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:34 PM   #18
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Ottawa, Canada
Posts: 327
Default

Do any of your 16 mysteries point to the existence of a creator/god? Would any of them be less of a mystery if god did 'em. At best they just leave the possibilty open. None of these mysteries are as mysterious as they were a century ago BTW.

Does something have to be understood with absolute certainty and in the greatest detail in order not to be a mystery?

Quote:
We are obviously cherrished creatures.
Can you give any evidence of this? Are we more cherrished than puffins or tulips or dragonflies?

Quote:
I used to accept evolution as a fact.
Then you should have been able to better anticipate the counter-arguments you would run into on these forums. Can you give us a quick synopsis of what you thought evolution was before your enlightenment? You seem to be a prolific typest so 500 words should be a snap.

Quote:
I see everything differently now. I see the truth. I feel His love.
This seems to me to be an emotional responce.
CreamFilledGiraffe is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:49 PM   #19
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Canada
Posts: 792
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
And by the way...

Why is it that food tastes so darn good?
Creatures that are revolted by the taste of food are less likely to survive long enough to produce offspring and are therefore less likely to pass on this trait to future generations.

However, it is not universally true that food tastes good. Many people dislike the taste of many things that are healthy and edible, and many people find some highly toxic substances quite tasty. There is considerable variation among different people. Generally speaking, though, things that taste good tend to be those things that are good for us--though due to our recently acquired ability to procure huge amounts of food, it is often now possible to consume to excess tasty things such as fat which were once hard to come by.

Quote:
Why is it that music sounds so darn good?
Music is composed by human beings. Some of it sounds good and some of it sounds bad, and different people make different judgements regarding which is which. Generally speaking, composers of music are more likely to compose music which they believe sounds good. There are all sorts of possible musical compositions, but we tend not to compose the ones that we would deem to be unpleasant.

You might as well ask why is it that buildings don't fall down. Some do, most don't. There are many conceivable ways to construct a building, but we tend to use the ones we have learned result in sturdy constructions and avoid those we have learned do not work well.

Quote:
Why is it that sex feels so darn good?
Creatures that find sex unpleasant are less likely to have sex and are therefore less likely to pass that trait on to their offspring. However, as with food, the extent to which people enjoy sex varies considerably. Some people do not find sex pleasant at all. Most people find sex pleasurable under certain circumstances and with certain people, but would find sex under different circumstances and with different partners to be highly traumatic.

Quote:
Why is it that hugs and massages feel so darn good?
The answer is similar to the answer regarding food and sex, as the formation of intimate human bonds are important to human evolution. And, as before, not everyone finds hugs and massage equally pleasant. In addition, most people who find hugs and massages from certain people to be pleasant would find the same hug or massage given by certain other people to be downright creepy and extremely uncomfortable. If you don't believe me, try going up to random people on the street and try to massage them. But be sure to retain a criminal lawyer first, as you will eventually end up getting arrested.

Quote:
Why is it that Creation looks so darn pretty?
Calling it creation begs the question, but I am sure you can easily think of many natural things that you find extremely unpleasant to look at. For example, what about the rotting carcass of a fawn that has been half devoured by wolves, or how about a writhing ball of maggots, or perhaps the sight of a blazing brushfire heading directly towards you? How about the sight of a family member's corpse, after an accidental fall onto some jagged rocks that split her head open, causing her brains to spill out? All part of nature or "creation."

Quote:
It seems to me that with all these things still mysteries, it would be hard for the average person to put so much faith in Godlessness. How could this world not be directed? It seems so obvious to me that we all are part of the Book of Life that God Created. Everything is so compicated on the inside (DNA, physics, chemistry, etc) yet so simple on the outside.
It seems the opposite to me: the smaller the scale at which you observe the universe, the simpler it is. A human being is an incredibly complex machine made up of an enormous number of parts and consisting of a large number of interdependent systems as well as an interdependence on the environment and other organisms ranging from simple bacteria to other humans. All of this is directed by simple DNA molecules.

None of this implies any kind of intelligence. There is simply no evidence that there is any purpose to the way nature works. Instead, nature appears to follow a fairly small set of universal and essentially arbitrary laws which have resulted in the universe we see before us. Had the laws been different, the Universe would have been different. Maybe it would have been less stable or interesting than the one we now live in, or maybe it would have been more stable or interesting. But there would have to be laws. A universe without natural laws would be hard to conceive, and impossible to understand.

Quote:
We are obviously cherrished creatures. We are walking miracles......and no matter how elegant neo-darwinism may be to you, it simply cannot explain miracles. Yet that's what you're living.
Miracle is just a term used by someone who doesn't understand what he is looking at and assumes that, because he does not understand, it must be a work of divine magic.
fishbulb is offline  
Old 08-05-2006, 09:59 PM   #20
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Korea
Posts: 572
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by supersport
goodness. Why are you blaming this on God who gave people free will to do what they want?

God could not have a true, loving relationship with humans if He did not give them free will.

Your anger is misdirected.
Goodness. Why are you blaming this on mankind? How does free will spawn a tsunami or volcanic eruption or virus or mudslide or heat wave or any other natural disaster?

If biblegod exists, how can you characterize subjecting mankind to misery and suffering as a loving relationship?

Your gullibility is unfortunate.
knotted paragon is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:36 PM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.