FRDB Archives

Freethought & Rationalism Archive

The archives are read only.


Go Back   FRDB Archives > Archives > Biblical Criticism - 2001
Welcome, Peter Kirby.
You last visited: Today at 05:55 AM

Notices

 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 09-26-2001, 01:22 PM   #21
Jebus
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: Connecticut
Posts: 43
Post

If you are interested in a commentary check out the New Jerome Biblical Commentary. You can also find many good books on various biblical topics written by HONEST christian scholars. I wouldn't consider Barker to be a qualified commentator on the Bible either. He has proven time and again that he doesn't know or understand the Bible.
Jebus is offline  
Old 09-26-2001, 02:02 PM   #22
diana
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Colorado Springs
Posts: 6,471
Post

Quote:
Originally posted by Kosh:
<STRONG>

"Only the REAL messiah would deny being
the messiah. HE IS! HE IS THE MESSIAH!"

- Monty Python really should be required
in the modern education system....

</STRONG>
BRIAN:
You're all individuals!

CROWD (as one):
We're all individuals!

MAN IN CROWD:
I'm not.

Of all the Monty Python movies, this is definitely one of them.

And QoS, "And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall set you free" has always been a favorite of mine.

d
diana is offline  
Old 09-26-2001, 02:08 PM   #23
diana
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Colorado Springs
Posts: 6,471
Post

Oh, and Xtopher...

I've found reading the Bible to be indispensible if you wish to argue against it. It's difficult to get and keep the attention of believers with straight philosophy. You stand a better chance of having your objections heard and considered if you meet them on their own turf.

Some atheists are happy to just be atheists. Others of us like to lock horns with believers. Personally, I'm boning up for the inevitable family feud. When it happens, I plan to know far more about their holy book than they do.

But for entertainment? More interesting to watch flies fuck.

d
diana is offline  
Old 10-05-2001, 01:37 PM   #24
lpetrich
Contributor
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Lebanon, OR, USA
Posts: 16,829
Post

Quote:
Originally posted by diana:
<STRONG>
Some atheists are happy to just be atheists. Others of us like to lock horns with believers. Personally, I'm boning up for the inevitable family feud. When it happens, I plan to know far more about their holy book than they do.
</STRONG>
Which reminds me of something very amusing from the later years of the Soviet Union: people were advised to be careful when invoking Lenin around some Party bosses, because those bosses may not be very familiar with Lenin's writings.

Yes, there was a big quasi-religious personality cult of Lenin there. "Lenin Lived, Lenin Lives, Lenin Will Live!" Children were taught about "Uncle Lenin". His body, or some wax substitute, was carefully preserved in his Red Square tomb in Moscow. Etc.
lpetrich is offline  
Old 10-05-2001, 08:53 PM   #25
Metacrock
Banned
 
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Dallas, Texas, USA
Posts: 1,734
Post

Quote:
Originally posted by Xtopher:
<STRONG>I once tried to read it from cover to cover when I was about 12 years old because someone told me you could add seven years to your life every time you read the whole thing. I got through the first few books and begat a great headache when I got to the geneologies, so I gave it up and haven't had the gumption to pick it up again since.

Obviously, many of those who post here (theists and non-theists alike) have an extensive knowledge of the bible and have probably read the whole darn thing several times (you should live to be about 140 yrs old ).

I don't have to read the bible to affirm my disbelief of xianity, but I think I might actually get a kick out of reading it with my "new" perspective and improve my ability to intelligently argue my position with xian friends.

Blatant generalization follows: most xians assume we atheists want nothing to do with god and the bible (true) and therefore have rejected religion without so much as a second thought so we can sin all we want and be as wicked as we want to without any rules (far from true). So, if anything, I'll read it just so I can slap a pompous xian upside the head with it if he waves it in front of me and ask if he has read teh whole goddam thing like I have.

I am interested as to how many non-theists out there see some value in reading the bible as a non-theist (xians need not tell me your perceived "value" in reading the bible -- lemme guess). Are many of you driven to read it as a matter of self-affirmation? Or would I be wasting time better spent reading philosophers / other materials?

Thanks for your input.

[ August 02, 2001: Message edited by: Xtopher ]</STRONG>
You might try reading more slowly. No one says you have to finnish in one sitting. you might also try thinking about what you read.

Now let's assume that reading the Bible might lead one to take part in religious acitivities, right? So if there is benifit to that, than one could say that there is benifit in reading the Bible right?

http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/coh_spr.htm

Cities on a Hill News Letter Spring 1999


Social Scientists Agree: Religious Belief Reduces Crime
Summary of the First Panel DiscussionPanelists for this important discussion included social scientists Dr. John DiIulio, professor of politics and urban affairs at Princeton University; David Larson, M.D., President of the National Institute for Healthcare Research; Dr. Byron Johnson, Director of the Center for Crime and Justice Policy at Vanderbilt University; and Gary Walker, President of Public/Private Ventures.  The panel focused on new research, confirming the positive effects that religiosity has on turning around the lives of youth at risk.
From left to right: Midge Decter, John DiIulio, David Larson, Byron Johnson and Gary Walker.

Dr. Larson laid the foundation for the discussion by summarizing the findings of 400 studies on juvenile delinquency, conducted during the past two decades.  He believes that although more research is needed, we can say without a doubt that religion makes a positive contribution.  His conclusion: “The better we study religion, the more we find it makes a difference.”Previewing his own impressive research, Dr. Johnson agreed.  He has concluded that church attendance reduces delinquency among boys even when controlling for a number of other factors including age, family structure, family size, and welfare status.  His findings held equally valid for young men of all races and ethnicities. Gary Walker has spent 25 years designing, developing and evaluating many of the nation’s largest public and philanthropic initiatives for at-risk youth.  His experience tells him that faith-based programs are vitally important for two reasons.  First, government programs seldom have any lasting positive effect.  While the government might be able to design programs that occupy time, these programs, in the long-term, rarely succeed in bringing about the behaviorial changes needed to turn kids away from crime.Second, faith-based programs are rooted in building strong adult-youth relationships; and less concerned with training, schooling, and providing services, which don’t have the same direct impact on individual behavior.  Successful mentoring, Walker added, requires a real commitment from the adults involved – and a willingess to be blunt.  The message of effective mentors is simple.  “You need to change your life, I’m here to help you do it, or you need to be put away, away from the community.”  Government, and even secular philanthropic programs, can’t impart this kind of straight talk.Walker is working on a pilot project with Dr. DiIulio and Rev. Eugene Rivers to implement a faith-based mentoring system in 10 cities around the country.  But the project faces some daunting challenges, as Mr. Walker sees it.  Can faith-based mentoring, which usually works on a small-scale, informal basis, be successfully bureaucratized, even by private organizations?  And can faith-based mentoring overcome resistance from government and philanthropic funders in order to grow and thrive?


People smart in different ways
http://www.mindpub.com/art162.htm

Rail http://www.inviteafriend.org/research.htm

Attending services is the most significant factor in predicting charitable giving. Robert Wunthnow, Acts of Compassion, Princeton University Press, 1991.
 
[] Attending services is the most significant factor in predicting volunteer activity. Ibid.
 
[] Sixth through twelfth graders who attend religious services once a month or more are half as likely to engage in at-risk behaviors such as substance abuse, sexual excess, truancy, vandalism, drunk driving and other trouble with police. Search Institute, "The Faith Factor," Source, Vol. 3, Feb. 1992, p.1.
 
[] Churchgoers are more likely to aid their neighbors in need than are non-attendees. George Barna, What Americans Believe, Regal Books, 1991, p. 226.
 
[] Three out of four Americans say that religious practice has strengthened family relationships. George Gallup, Jr. "Religion in America: Will the Vitality of Churches Be the Surprise of the Next Century," The Public Perspective, The Roper Center, Oct./Nov. 1995.
 
[] Church attendance lessens the probabilities of homicide and incarceration. Nadia M. Parson and James K. Mikawa: "Incarceration of African-American Men Raised in Black Christian Churches." The Journal of Psychology, Vol. 125, 1990, pp.163-173.
 
[] Religious practice lowers the rate of suicide. Joubert, Charles E., "Religious Nonaffiliation in Relation to Suicide, Murder, Rape and Illegitimacy," Psychological Reports 75:1 part 1 (1994): 10 Jon W. Hoelter: "Religiosity, Fear of Death and Suicide Acceptibility." Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, Vol. 9, 1979, pp.163-172.
 


The presence of active churches, synagogues, or mosques reduces violent crime in neighborhoods. John J. Dilulio, Jr., "Building Spiritual Capital: How Religious Congregations Cut Crime and Enhance Community Well-Being," RIAL Update, Spring 1996.
 
[] People with religious faith are less likely to be school drop-outs, single parents, divorced, drug or alcohol abusers. Ronald J. Sider and Heidi Roland, "Correcting the Welfare Tragedy," The Center for Public Justice, 1994.
 
[] Church involvement is the single most important factor in enabling inner-city black males to escape the destructive cycle of the ghetto. Richard B. Freeman and Harry J. Holzer, eds., The Black Youth Employment Crisis, University of Chicago Press, 1986, p.354.
 
[] Attending services at a church or other house of worship once a month or more makes a person more than twice as likely to stay married than a person who attends once a year or less. David B. Larson and Susan S. Larson, "Is Divorce Hazardous to Your Health?" Physician, June 1990.
Improving Personal Well-Being

[] Most happy people are also religious people.

96% of people who say they are generally happy agree that "My religious faith is the most important influence in my life." George Gallup, Jr. "Religion in America: Will the Vitality of Churches Be the Surprise of the Next Century?", The Public Perspective, The Roper Center, Oct./Nov. 1995.


[] Most people who find their work exciting and fulfilling are religious people.


&lt;65% of people who say their occupation is exciting and fulfilling say that they find "comfort and support from my religious beliefs." Ibid.

[] Most people who are excited about the future are religious people.

&gt;80% of those who say they are "excited about the future" agree that they find "comfort and support from my religious beliefs." Ibid.

[] Most people who feel close to their families are religious people.

94% of people who "feel very close" to their families agree that "my religious faith is the most important influence in my life." Ibid.

[] Eight in ten Americans say religious beliefs help them respect themselves. Ibid.
[] More than eight in ten say that their religious beliefs lead them to respect people of other religions. Ibid.

 Improving Health

[] Regular church attendance lessens the possibility of cardiovascular diseases, cirrhosis of the liver, emphysema and arteriosclerosis. George W. Comstock amd Kay B. Patridge:  "Church attendance and health."  Journal of Chronic Disease, Vol. 25, 1972, pp. 665-672.

 [] Regular church attendance significantly reduces the probablility of high blood pressure.  David B. Larson, H. G. Koenig, B. H. Kaplan, R. S. Greenberg, E. Logue and H. A. Tyroler:  " The Impact of religion on men's blood pressure."  Journal of Religion and Health, Vol. 28, 1989, pp.265-278.  W.T. Maramot:  "Diet, Hypertension and Stroke." in  M. R. Turner (ed.) Nutrition and Health, Alan R. Liss, New York, 1982, p. 243.

 [] People who attend services at least once a week are much less likely to have high blood levels of interlukin-6, an immune system protein associated with many age-related diseases.  Harold Koenig and Harvey Cohen, The International Journal of Psychiatry and Medicine, October 1997.

 [] Regular practice of religion lessens depression and enhances self esteem.  Peter L. Bensen and Barnard P. Spilka:  "God-Image as a function of self-esteem and locus of control" in H. N. Maloney (ed.) Current Perspectives in the Psychology of Religion, Eedermans, Grand Rapids, 1977, pp. 209-224.  Carl Jung: "Psychotherapies on the Clergy" in Collected Works Vol. 2, 1969, pp.327-347.

 [] About half of religious people "have a lot of stress" in their lives, but only half of these "often get depressed." George Gallup, Jr. "Religion in America: Will the Vitality of Churches Be the Surprise of the Next Century?" The Public Perspective, The Roper Center, Oct./Nov. 1995.

 [] Church attendance is a primary factor in preventing substance abuse and repairing damage caused by substance abuse.  Edward M. Adalf and Reginald G. Smart:  "Drug Use and Religious Affiliation, Feelings and Behavior."   British Journal of Addiction, Vol. 80, 1985, pp.163-171.  Jerald G. Bachman, Lloyd D. Johnson, and Patrick M. O'Malley:  "Explaining  the Recent Decline in Cocaine Use Among Young Adults:  Further Evidence That Perceived Risks and Disapproval Lead to Reduced Drug Use."  Journal of Health and Social Behavior, Vol. 31,  1990, pp. 173-184.  Deborah Hasin, Jean Endicott,   and Collins Lewis:  "Alcohol and Drug Abuse in Patients With Affective Syndromes."  Comprehensive Psychiatry, Vol. 26, 1985, pp. 283-295.   The findings of this NIMH-supported study were repilcated in the Bachmen et. al. study above.

 
This data is reprinted from RIAL Update which is edited by Robert B. Lennick and published twice a year by Religion In American Life.  Reprinting of any material in this copyright publication requires written permission from the editor.
http://www.bangor.ac.uk/rs/ms/monitoring.html

W.K. Kay and L.J. Francis
Drift from the Churches: attitudes towards Christianity during childhood and adolescence, Cardiff, University of Wales Press, 1996, pp x + 266Key words: attitudes - Christianity - children - adolescents - empiricalMedium: authored bookSummary:

How and why do some young people become religious?  Are religious people happier than others?  Do church schools help pupils to develop a positive attitude toward Christianity?  What part does personal religious experience play in shaping religious attitudes?  Twenty-five years of empirical psychological and sociological research on young people in relation to Christianity is presented here in a set of interrelated studies which show how attitude toward Christianity in young people is linked with schooling, cognitive development, masculinity and femininity, church attendance, religious experience, science, well-being, mental health and the Eysenckian model of personality.

[ October 05, 2001: Message edited by: Metacrock ]
Metacrock is offline  
Old 10-05-2001, 11:50 PM   #26
sh0k0nes
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: London, England
Posts: 8
Post

Hey Xtopher,

I was raised a Christian before I read the Bible. Brought up on stories of Yashua looking like a long haired hippy.

When I did try to read it I found it was a load of nonsensical stories. I had that perplexed look that I get when I read some of Nomad's posts. You know the one, when you look at the camera, raise your shoulders and say 'huh'.
I eventually got through all of it.
This was way before I realised I was an athiest.
I personally don't it has any use outside being able to counter Christians claims. I have read far better books and comics.

As an aside I also read the Quran. Now if you want real gibberish, that takes the bisquit!!

Kev
sh0k0nes is offline  
Old 10-06-2001, 01:55 AM   #27
zenman
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: California
Posts: 65
Post

The benefit from reading the bible is this

first reading all that fine print causes eye strain, which strengthens the eyes, second it keeps you busy so you wont be doing other foolish things, and it makes you sound impressive, Ive read the whole bible cover to cover, big Ego boost.


Zenman
zenman is offline  
Old 10-09-2001, 05:51 PM   #28
Loki
Veteran Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Land of hippies and fog
Posts: 2,075
Post

I wish i could remember the quote and the author: something to the extent of comparing a religious man and a nonreligious man and noting that the fact that religious man is happier means about as much as the fact that a drunk man is happier than a sober one.

I read the bible for poetry occasionally, mythology often, and the occasional anti-theistic argument.

Actually, Gen 3 is one of my favorite stories of any culture. But it's been grossly misinterpreted by the religions which believe in it.
Loki is offline  
Old 10-14-2001, 11:02 AM   #29
Berenger Sauniere
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: et in Arcadia ego...
Posts: 406
Post

I've used it many years for research purposes but keep it placed on my bookshelf upside down when not being used. Turning something upside down was the Egyptian way of designating destruction. My way of saying I'm going to topple the bible/religion.
Berenger Sauniere is offline  
Old 10-14-2001, 11:56 AM   #30
Dolphin
Regular Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: England, University of Durham
Posts: 153
Post

Quote:
Originally posted by Berenger Sauniere:
<STRONG> Turning something upside down was the Egyptian way of designating destruction. My way of saying I'm going to topple the bible/religion.</STRONG>
Damn, due to my haste in putting books away I've declared myself a destroyer of some pretty good books.
Dolphin is offline  
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:33 PM.

Top

This custom BB emulates vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.